Originally Posted by
David Puddy
Wrong about the CS100s. I have no affiliation with Bombardier or UAL, but I need to offer some corrections. First, the order in question is for 40 CS300s - these aircraft are bigger than the CS100 by 20-35 seats depending upon the configuration. Republic originally ordered them for Frontier to replace Airbuses. And by the way, this airplane is super-advanced with very fuel efficient engines (GTF), FBW, side sticks and Collins ProLine Fusion cockpit (like what you find in high-end Global Express biz jets - it makes the 787 cockpit look old) with HUD - it puts the E190/95 to shame. Here's a cockpit photo from the smaller CS100 that SWISS will operate:
Photos: Bombardier CSeries CS100 (BD-500-1A10) Aircraft Pictures | Airliners.net
Meanwhile Air Canada can't wait to dump their E190s and traded them off to Boeing when they ordered the 737MAX. So, if they aren't good enough for Air Canada, why should UAL want them? I am not saying the E190 is terrible aircraft - it just can't compare to the CS300 in terms of performance and innovation.
The CS300 can also fly from Ft. Meyers to Seattle full in the summer (big overhead bins for the pax) or to Hawaii from smaller California airports and will soon be certified to land at London City Airport (steep approach and short runway). This isn't a dilapidated/worn A319 or 737-700. Recall that the C-Series program was largely delayed due to an engine fire - it wasn't Bombardier's fault but it suffered a big cash loss due to the resulting 6-month delay.
This airplane, compared objectively with the E195, A319 and the 737-700 is a GAME CHANGER. This is not a Q400 with jets or a junky stretched CRJ. Th program needs some serious momentum from bigger orders and UAL potentially taking Republic's order for 40 CS300s would be very helpful to the program.
my mistake, the republic order is for the larger CS300 however I don't think that's the plane that United is interested in. The whole reason for the search for a new type was to fill the gap between 76 seat RJs and the 319/737-700. The CS100 is right in the middle and could potentially replace a lot of RJ flying. I don't see United making a big investment in the 125-150 seat market when they can obviously find used 319s fairly easily.