If we were truly only $47mil from the company's proposal we have real problems yes.

The issue with putting out the unions position to the group is it gets guys negotiating in public which can compromise our position, but that's already happened with the company's side being published which is why I wonder it was put out. Not to mention that they are probably bound by non disclosure agreements so it must have been done with the company's permission. That means it has to be part of a bigger strategy by the company that we (our negotiators) fell victim to. I'm interested to know why it was put out. Get the foil hats ready.