criticism - the act of making careful judgments about good and bad qualities (usually when evaluating art)

examination would have been a better choice of word.

No negative connotation intended. I gotta use more emojis.

I think this could work. If there's a flaw in the logic, I'll move on. Doesn't matter in relation to the vote but we have to find a better score card for scope or we lose the KISS principle and the interpretations are twisted.