Long time lurker, yet minimalist poster here on APC. Was a NO voter on TA-1.
When I ask those that I fly with (more so in the bar in NRT) about this TA and about Web Forums, my response rate currently runs about 95% with "This TA is fine even though I don't like everything about it", and "The forums are too negative, so I don't read them."
I'm a Yes voter on this TA, but like the remaining 5% of those I ask, I read APC to see if I've missed something. I do learn some specific things from time to time that I didn't have a firm grasp on previously, but seeing the CC post here about 'trolls' and such elicited a desire to back up Scoop (even though I've no idea who he is) on the attempted hysteria of the "No" crowd.
Kudos to Scoop and Clamp for bringing moderation to an anonymous forum, and hopefully the postings here can be full truths, not partial, and without personal attacks despite disagreements.