Originally Posted by
dontcare4U
Really? If you can't land you deserve to pass? Come on. You're smarter than that. He did fine elsewhere in the ride, and the instructor certainly was not an idiot.
If you can't land a simulator it's irrelevant.
You're right. I am pretty smart...and experienced. I've never heard of someone failing training or failing in a simulator because of their landings.
If someone is failing a sim session or checkride because of the landing, which I've never seen graded at any level, ever, then that person had something else happening, not just landings.