I see no issue, since you got the old logbook back. You may even want to attach a copy of the police report, though I really don't think it's a big deal. I had my both my logbooks stolen, along with a rental car, clothes on an interview trip I had a a number of years ago. I was very lucky that I had made an Excel logbook program and had that on my hard drive at home. Still the Excel log didn't contain my first ~225hrs. I was able to partially reconstruct those time from my FAA records. I now only keep a electronic log book. I have about 5 back-ups, CD-Rom, memory sticks and on two separate computers. I keep one memory stick in a safety deposit box. I do keep a paper logbook also, updating it once a month by printing a new page. I've been on a couple interviews so far and have yet to be even questioned about my original logbooks. I have been complemented on the layout and neatness of my current logbook. BTW - I now use Safelog instead of Excel, very happy with it.

So far I have been offered a job at each place I have interviewed with.