Originally Posted by
Spartan07
Thanks NE, appreciate it! But it is okay for both the CFI and the student to log PIC once the student has their Private (ie: is rated to fly the aircraft)
Yes, that is one of the situations where both pilots can log PIC, the CFI is the acting PIC (i.e. if something goes wrong it is on their certificate), whereas the student is logging PIC since they are the sole-manipulator of the controls for an aircraft which they are rated to fly.