“MEC had in their hands our latest proposal.” Seems very clear to me? “In addition, JetBlue offered..” this is clearly written by JetBlue’s management about their offer to ALPA. Why would you think ALPA proposed/wrote that?

Management proposed to JB ALPA Alaska - 1%, with scheduling concessions (concessions from what we don’t know...current, proposed, already agreeed upon, etc.). Regardless, Alaska -1% isn’t the market rate, even for Alaska, since they get a raise in april. AA/DAL/UAL/SWA/HAL also need to be thrown in to establish “market rate.”