Originally Posted by Spicy McHaggis

There are a ton of pilots living out in PA, though more live in the Lehigh Valley than the Route 80 Delaware Water Gap I think. You time sounds right with the anticipation that morning rush hour will add some time. For me, coming out of the Lehigh Valley it's about 1:10 to the EWR parking lot under normal time with rush hour adding 20min at most under normal conditions (accident or whatever, good luck). It's about 1:45-2:00 to LGA in non-rush hour traffic.

The 757/767 in EWR for the most part doesn't do any LGA flying and a lot of the trips start in the late afternoon early evening and finish before the afternoon rush hour.