Perhaps my numbers are skewed because I put in retiring at 60. The numbers look far better if you stick it out to 65. But I don't want to do that, and I hate that people might feel they need to keep working because of the potential for a better retirement. I think that overall this plan is going to benefit very few people, and who can trust a calculator that the union puts out?

This seems insane that we are wasting our resources towards negotiating an uncertain, complicated plan that will probably not be anything like we expect.