Well, looks like I screwed myself with this one. Moral of the story: Unless you REALLY want the day off restored, don't ask for it. You will more than likely lose money, since whatever pay credit you were gonna get on that day will be lost. And the 5 hours Add Pay in lieu of the day off is at the discretion of the scheduler. He made that abundantly clear to me on the phone. So basically if you need a day off, find another way of getting it!