Originally Posted by
Naviator
There were 10 FOs with enough hours that did not upgrade last round.
What is your source for this information? Do you know that those ten people had the 950 hours BEFORE the bid closed? Do you know their circumstances? Pretty sure if you had an unsat in recurrent you could not immediately upgrade.
If there were people who were not “15 G 4’d” that should have been and someone senior was, there would have been a grievance.