No question at all.

Mesaba street captain.

There is no question Mesaba is the best choice. First, turbine PIC is the important time. Mesaba has been growing big time over the past year. Lynx is filled with captains who had a decent amount of experience, so they are not as interested in moving on. Trust me that attrition at Lynx will not be like attrition at Mesaba (atleast over the next few years). The pay is twice to three times better at Mesaba (isn't that reason enough).

Honestly, I think Lynx is one of the worst regionals out there specifically because of their pay ($50/hour for 74 seat captain). Yes, I would say Lynx is worse than Colgan.

Go to Mesaba.