I’ve overnighted in both places, albeit several years ago when i was still on the guppy. I definitely prefer Cabo over PVR personally. Both places are nice, especially when its 20 degrees in EWR!! In Cabo, the crews were moved several times due to a hurricane that wiped out the Hilton we stayed at, which was very nice but not an “all-inclusive”. The last place we stayed at was the Barcelo Gran Faro Los Cabos. Absolutely beautiful and an all inclusive right on the beach. Had several 24 hour layovers there and it was awesome. PVR just seamed a little more “Wal-Mart-ish” to me. But having said that, I didn’t do too many overnights there. Hope that helps.