It seems you only use company provided information. The union put out an email with a graph showing the approximate return of each.[/QUOTE]

I read it. Go back and read the details. The savings are dealing with the two month period coming up and how we meet the companies goals. Note however that they admit they applied savings from a ER program that would accumulate through the end 2020. They also toss in the APR rebid. Other than that they provide no real numbers. A 20 hour a month reduction spread across at most probably 3000 pilots verses a 16 hour a month reduction spread across 14,000 pilots seems pretty simple math to me.