Explain to me how all 1000 pilots would have got line valve and a bonus if they work a little? you think all of those 1000 would be a line holder? For Example, there was only 38 lines in LAS and 74 who took the VIL. As a commuter, and on reserve, i would be using my commuter clause for just about everything time I had an LCR assignment, (due to the reduce flight schedules) or sit in the crash pad for 2/3 of the month. Many commuter didn't want to deal with that especially if they knew they would be on reserve.