I also interviewed at both ASA and Mesaba. I was also offered a job at both. So I really feel your pain. Both are great places to work and I am greatfull to have been lucky enough to have to make the hard decision. I ended up choosing the Mesaba job, but it did take some major thought. I am glad of my decision, but one thing that I did not account for in my research was that it will take me longer to actually start at mesaba. I interviewed at asa on 12/09 and class was to start on 12/27. I interviewed at measba on 12/18 and got a 3/10 class. Soooo....if you are poor and need to start right away......?