Honestly, I think the ASA pilots accepted a subpar contract compared to what they could have gotten. Even with their raises, they are still well below Horizon, Republic, Expressjet, Eagle. And now with Pinnacle, Mesa, Horizon, Republic, and a few others starting negotiations, they will be towards the bottom of the totem poll very shortly. I think ASA caved on their TA.
I think (and hope) that Pinnacle will hold out for much better than ASA. How about shooting above Expressjet, or Republic, or maybe even Horizon. A strike would help your chances of achieving these rates.