Norskman,
Thank you very much for the informative post.
I think CAE is a great alternative. I've actually done some training at their center in DEN and in PHX, and have always been very impressed. I know what you mean about Pinnacle, but it might be a much better option than Mesa.
I was once at Mesa and was lucky enough to never have been on reserve there. Things worked out great and I enjoyed the poeple I flew with and the options it once presented. It has changed a lot though in the last 5 years.... I wish them all the best, but it might be time to reap what some people in management have sown. Because of this, I might be recommending this different option to my friend. Ultimately his decision, but want to help him get the best information possible.
Thanks again.
Since you offered, I might PM you with a few additional questions.