FWIW, I believe there were 2 NY 765 slots left available off the last AE, and they have both gone out. I would scratch that off the available list.
MCO is probably just as easy a commute as ATL, in part because there are 2 (really 3) options to get there. NY 7ER would be a pretty sweet deal for you, not even including the possibility of MCO Layovers.
Gos luck.