Not baiting (not intending to anyway) thanks for not playing. On the surface that seems like such a complete betrayal of trust and complete abuse of the PDR system.

However, are the data points collected in order for ALPA to advocate or correct issues on the pilots behalf? On specific events, it may not be hard for management to figure out the “who” if it’s a one off. For the bulk of PDRs you’d hope it’s trend management/awareness.

I hope that pilot gets a good settlement in DFR suit if he was mistreated.