View Single Post
Old 11-24-2023 | 05:04 PM
  #211  
nene
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Nov 2020
Posts: 2,248
Likes: 103
Default

Originally Posted by symbian simian
Cool story. So quote me "the rule that all promotion boards be staffed with females and minorities already".
Perhaps I wasn't as clear as possible. Even before DEI was "a thing", at least in the 90's and 2000's when I was involved in them, the US Navy required all promotion and selection boards to have a minority and female member (yes, among the other 8 probably white males) to ensure that the process was properly considering all aspects of the services desire to ensure properly qualified female and minorities were promoted to the max extent possible, which was generally stated as a precept of each board.

Over those periods, depending on the economy, manning, and needs of the service, sometimes it was easy to promote as many as possible. Sometimes the conditions made it so the selection rates were very slim.

My whole point of recalling the picture in record decision was that before that decision, it was assumed that if enough women and minorities didn't get selected it was because some on the board saw the picture and were racist/sexist (despite women and minorities being on the board).
But the reality proved quickly, without the picture, board members could not tell who to give extra consideration to, and selection rates fell when just considering records.

The Navy used to consider "pain points" when looking at records so a sailor/airmen that had done many deployments would generally been considered ahead of another that had less. I remember the female board rep usually giving the reminder that a female that was making the Navy a career and also desired a family was bound to be more constrained to volunteering for Navy pain for the sake of advancement, likewise the minority rep would remind board members that many minority sailors/airmen came from disadvantaged backgrounds so if it took a bit for them to hit their stride in their career, that may be a possible explanations. Never were we encouraged to promote anyone who wasn't qualifiied, it was just often the promotion/selection boards were quite competitve so there were more qualified personnel than were to be selected.

This was all before I had ever even heard of DEI. The Navy always has tried hard to find/train and promote minority leadership. But so has most companies, so the competition for the same talent is tight.

Last edited by nene; 11-24-2023 at 05:17 PM.
Reply