On the up or out at American captain upgrade, since 2001 it can be deferred up to like 3 years now, but you must write a statement to your chief or something. I see it in the computer when looking at the bid results who has deferred.

I think our union wants it changed due to the massive amount of commuters we have. That it's a different landscape now. Since 2001, many if not all of us have decided whats more important "your family life or your seat"
This is just my guess.
But more likely it's to match the other majors that do not have a up or out policy.
Me, i'll upgrade at first chance available. But that's just me.

I like the policy and because it's fair, this way everyone gets a shot at "The On Reserve Experience" Whooppee!