Like I said, this merger is infinitely more complicated. Way more variables, way higher probability that unforseen circumstances of various integration decisions have detrimental effects on this pilot group. What you call "takes" are actually well thought out statements based on past precedent of this company, the history of mergers in this country, and objectively looking at the variables at play and how they will effect (affect?) pilot careers. One line little quips without thougt out explanation of your position are in fact "takes".