I’m talking about your certainty that the TA was never about being a stop gap, it was only about stemming attrition, ALPA playing right into “their” hand. They would have given us more, because otherwise Spirit wouldn’t be around. Giving in to our demands being a red flag. This is the stuff that you are imagining to be true. You have no way of knowing these things. And now you’re using the things that you imagined to be true to be the things from which to learn.

Nothing wrong with learning from the past. You are not doing that. You are “learning” from imagination. You can’t insert opinions and biases as fact. You are keeping the answer of “we should have voted no” and now just searching for evidence to support it.