Originally Posted by
sgrd0q
Sorry, but this is where the system is broken. Make everyone go around any time there is an alert.
The system is not broken. The CA system is not designed to prevent mid-airs. It is designed to prevent controllers from getting distracted. To relate it to TCAS, it's more like a TA than an RA. When it goes off, the controller has to verify that at least one of the pilots is maintaining visual separation. It would be really hard to make a system that is sensitive enough the distinguish an actual potential mid-air vs. a plane that is pointing at an aircraft on a parallel runway but is going to turn final before they actually hit.