Originally Posted by
SideStickMonkey
First off, I vote for option #2.
Absolutely not. Taskings pop up, people do have an obligation to their reserve or guard unit that didn't exist two days ago. One of my units did a lot of DSCA (Defense Support of Civil Authorities) ie disaster relief. So the idea of being punished by for having to go help with a flood or hurricane is ludicrous.
So no, absolutely no.
You're not being punished. It's not even close. That's like saying you are getting punished for calling in sick by not retaining priority for your green slip that you were only eligible for by calling in sick. It's not even an arguement.
If your MLOA had no bearing on your effect to pick up silver slips then you retain your priority. You're just not getting a good deal at the expense of the pilot group.