Have you ever flown night freight? There's a reason most of them jumped at the chance to go to a regional.

Airnet is a great company and a great fit for many people, but let's not say that it would be better for the average pilot. Flying all night by yourself regardless of the radar or icing is paying dues. It's not the same as Comair by any stretch of the imagination.

With all that said, the current industry dictates that your choices are narrowed for probably the next year or so. If I were in your shoes I would go to Airnet, but I would prefer Comair.

Best of luck to you regardless.