It would be nice if the AOPA got involved with this! The policy basicly says "you must take the FALANT test at every exam rather than only once". This policy is discriminating against people with minor color deficiencies because:
1.) Only a few AME's in the country have the FALANT test, and they will retire eventually. People should not have to spend hundreds or thousands of dollars just to make special trips across the country for every exam!
2.) New AME's are not using the FALANT because they don't make them anymore!
3.) If this was such a safety issue, they would be pulling all the existing LOE's for the FALANT test!
4.) Are they arguing that color vision changes over time, since they sill issue LOE's, but only if you complete their extensive OVCT and MFT test! For what reason is the FALANT test still allowed, but it must be demonstrated at every exam?
5.) The failure of the OVCT test will restrict you for life! This test is conducted in an uncontrolled environment, at airports with different equipment. The weather and/or time of day can make the test easier or harder. It is even recommended to take the test when the daylight is not directly overhead, but this is not always possible.
Conclusion: People who invest tens of thousands of dollars and time into their careers don't deserve to loose it years down the road because they can't find a FALANT test, or they fail the OCVT! It is pure discrimination when you make a certain group of people have to spend LOTS of extra money at every exam. In my opinion, this policy violates the (ADA) American's with Disabilities Act.