Seems as though not everyone agrees with you, chair. From TonyW himself:

"The grossly unscientific poll I saw on the SAPA forum was that 25% supported Up-n-Out."

That leaves 75% who don't support it.

Here's an unanswered question. Besides AA, who else has this policy? Anybody? Why would Skywest pilots support a policy that seems to be quite rare in the industry?