Originally Posted by
Ferd149
I promised myself I'd stay off this thread, but I can't help myself.
I still believe your concerns were covered in cross and are not an issue.
Cog........here is my offer. Lets go through the Delta closing argument when it comes out today, and if this is mentioned by your lawyer as an issue, I will gladly and publicly apologize for what I've said. I elected a rep who elected a merger committee (yes different from your system) so we are in fact all somewhat responsible.
If not, we let it all go and move on together. Deal?
Ferd
Originally Posted by
Cogf16
Deal Out of town and haven't seen the transcripts. What was the verdict.
Cog
Originally Posted by
Cogf16
You too Fred. Last beating of the dead horse! I get that the hearings are over and we are arguing over mute points but it still bothers me that, A- any of this is true, and B- few if any NWA guys seem to be troubled by it, and C- how will/did it affect the arbitors decision.
Happy Thanksgiving from 80 degree PHX
Cog
Cog,
Well, I went through your closing (abet quickly
) and I don’t see anywhere that you guys describe us as being dishonest. There are a few choice words – wrong headed (p27), flawed assumptions (p32) faulty assumptions (p34). They did describe Tom Dolloway as “less than credible” and that he had a “mischaracterization of delta scheduling provisions (p38).
There is a big discussion on the differences of the snap shot used. We used 1 Jan 2008 and you guys used 1 July 2008. My instinct would have been to use the latest available (that military thinking thing) but we talk about it too in our closing. We may differ in whether the justification makes since but at least both sides are presented.
It was hard reading your closing. I felt pretty beat up reading it so I don’t think you guys are worried that we are getting away with anything that they haven’t caught. On a personal note, I liked your closing (more case law cited) than ours, but I haven’t read all of ours yet.
I agree with the other thread………let’s wait for the smoke to clear after the 8th (or sooner?) and see what Santa Bloch brings. Peace?
Ferd
Last edited by Ferd149; 11-24-2008 at 09:58 AM.