I'm not knowledgable enough on the facts concerning the unions and airlines in this case but I agree with exwaterski here that safety has been comprimised at the hands of the judicial system and the judge who allowed ASAP reports released in a lawsuit.
My community is already having a hard time accepting the ASAP program and I'm sure that this will just add ammunition to those who never believed in it to begin with in the first place.

USMCFLYR