The Judge has said we have to pay dues, but will be exempt from any damages awarded, in other words if we win damages usapa must bifurcate the west class dues from the damages. As of right now we are challenging their germane dues, the average germane dues are 65 to 80% usapa has an unbelievable 95% germane rate. Oh yeah 50% of their budget goes to the law firm that keeps telling them they can still overturn arbitration with plans to appeal to the us supreme court.