Yeah, I agree with you TProp, but I think this is the flaw in your thinking:

The situation that you just presented included a responsible, experienced captain and a responsible, life experienced (?) FO. What happens in your situation when the recently upgraded captain with 50 PIC total is trying to mentor the 200 hr guy with the wet commercial?

I put the question mark in there because I don't know your experience, but rickair alluded to the fact that you have "life experience". I meant this situation I presented to be as respectful towards you and the captain as possible while contrasting it to a couple characters that were not as experienced.


Also, this brings up a strange situation. Now these "fresh" ATP's may be flying with captains that have 1/20th the PIC time.