He crashed because he wasn't competent the fundamentals. Wasn't comfortable with stalls. That is to be learned in the very beginning, and mastered while a CFI. The guy didn't know how to recover from stalls. Important skill as a pilot. Colgan overlooked a lot of the guys history because they needed people to work at the level they were willing to pay. He was willing and eventually, in their opinion, a future captain. Colgan couldn't be selective. Guessing he probably didn't practice too much stall recovery at Gulfstream. Both these pilots went to Colgan for the quick upgrade then to move on to make the big bucks, the FO said it herself on the tapes. That is the real problem: shortcuts. Everyone wants the quick way to the money that we have been told would be waiting for us "if we pay our dues." Most of us are flying the big jets right now (70-90 seaters). This could be it folks.
Originally Posted by
BoilerUP
I fail to see your point.
He didn't crash the airplane when he was below 1500 hours, and got thousands of hours in Colgan airplanes in the Colgan system between hire and when the plane went down.
Delaying his hire until he had more than 1500 hours, using your example, is no guarantee that he wouldn't have still screwed the pooch on a simple stall recovery (to say nothing of not letting it happen in the first place).
So no, he being hired under 1500tt didn't have ANYTHING to do with this accident and would not have prevented it.
Also, while the raw facts support your hypothesis, using AMW 5481 is a long stretch...