Correct.
Incorrect.

You neglect to mention that every one of those Eagle pilots had an APA seniority number senior to the pilots you claim should have been placed before them. A more correct analogy would have been two airlines like NWA and Delta that furloughed pilots then merged lists. When the recall came, an arbitrator says all pilots should be recalled in order of the merged seniority list, but you are advocating that all "Delta" pilots should be recalled first since the airline is still called Delta. Sorry dude, but seniority rules and the arbitrator agreed. Complain all you want, but it's done and, IMHO, was done fairly.