"Personally I think choosing Key Lime over Colgan is a poor choice."
Personally, I think it's a great choice....
The chance for turbine PIC experience will come much sooner and you don't have to deal with a bottom feeder regional (no disrespect meant to bottom feeder regional pilots). I was on the UPS ramp at DEN a while back and Key Lime owns the feeder flying. I could see the QOL and pay as a Metro PIC being a much better deal than going the regional new hire route. It's all an individual choice. We had guys leave UPS in 1990 for America West cause they didn't really want to fly freight.
I know Key Lime has a bad rep on the net. I'd say check it out for oneself before one makes the call. Don't listen to us hosers that post on the interweb.
But by all means, good luck and let us know how it turns out, in any case.