That may be true, it is also probably true that doh will hurt the lower 50% of mesabas pilots. So are you suggesting, the junior 9e guys get together with the senior xj guys and play "let's ****** our buddies"? I just thought a some thought should be given to the fact that pre-purchase xj was going to furlough roughly half the list. The same consideration should be given to the fact that Colgan would never have the growth from the q400s if they had not been aquired and funded by Pinnacle. As long as those two factors weigh in to the sli I will think the outcome is "fair".