Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Allegiant (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/allegiant/)
-   -   Another Allegiant Fire (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/allegiant/53953-another-allegiant-fire.html)

cfiguy11 10-08-2010 06:06 AM

Another Allegiant Fire
 
Jetliner Catches Fire At Sanford Airport - Orlando News Story - WKMG Orlando

Gotta be a record. Isn't this like 3 this year?

BigTime 10-08-2010 07:12 AM

Actually that's #4 in the past 12 months. There goes Allegiant's hopes for ETOPS certification any time in the next year. Looks like it's time to buy an airline that already has it.

Fishfreighter 10-08-2010 08:35 AM

It took Alaska 720 days to get their ETOPS certification. Most of that was maintenance related setup issues. What makes Allegiant think they'll do any better, especially with their maintenance problems over the last 12 months.

mmaviator 10-08-2010 10:28 AM

http://nycaviation.com/2010/10/alleg...re-in-orlando/

captnmajic 10-08-2010 11:26 AM

Any of this reminiscent of a blast from the past know as ValuJet? At the current rate of incidents I give them 12-18 months before they have a fatal accident that results in the deaths of many people. Hopefully the FAA is watching and will take necessary steps to break the accident chain.

lear 31 pilot 10-08-2010 01:50 PM

Any talk of them getting newer aircraft to replace the MD 80s lately, or is that the only reason they have been profitable? How many engine fires has American had on their MD 80s in the last few years, I seem to remember a few.

Swedish Blender 10-08-2010 01:51 PM


Originally Posted by captnmajic (Post 881915)
Any of this reminiscent of a blast from the past know as ValuJet? At the current rate of incidents I give them 12-18 months before they have a fatal accident that results in the deaths of many people. Hopefully the FAA is watching and will take necessary steps to break the accident chain.

Valujet didn't crash due to maintenance FWIW. Not really apples to apples for such a statement.

Should someone say your airline will have a fatal crash in the next 12-18 months?

Grumble 10-08-2010 02:35 PM


Originally Posted by Swedish Blender (Post 881968)
Valujet didn't crash due to maintenance FWIW. Not really apples to apples for such a statement.

Should someone say your airline will have a fatal crash in the next 12-18 months?

Agreed, what was the company that loaded the cargo, Sabre Tech? IIRC they were found at fault. The accident just put ValueJet under the microscope and then things began to surface.

Back on topic, didn't Allegiant damn near kill 135 people a week ago rotating off the end of a 6500' runway with a calculated TO distance of something like 6525'?

Offwidth 10-08-2010 02:54 PM


Originally Posted by Swedish Blender (Post 881968)
Valujet didn't crash due to maintenance FWIW. Not really apples to apples for such a statement.

Should someone say your airline will have a fatal crash in the next 12-18 months?

Actually, it was Valujet's MX contractor Sabretech that put O2 generators in the holds, (with duct taped firing pins) to save a couple bucks. So yes, FWIW, that crash was due to maintenance.

It is this combination of poor maintenance and the lack of oversight from typical 2nd tier airline management that gets people killed.

MD80driver2day 10-08-2010 04:14 PM

To be clear... This was a tail pipe fire that occurred during start up and there was no evacuation. The airplane was pulled back into the gate and everyone deplaned.

This had nothing to do with maintenance, or lack thereof as most of you are suggesting.

Shiek Yiboudi 10-08-2010 06:01 PM


Originally Posted by captnmajic (Post 881915)
Any of this reminiscent of a blast from the past know as ValuJet? At the current rate of incidents I give them 12-18 months before they have a fatal accident that results in the deaths of many people. Hopefully the FAA is watching and will take necessary steps to break the accident chain.

What are you smoking? I think we have a winner for the worst post in APC! What a terrible thing to say. Like MD80driver said, it was an unfortunate event that happened to a great guy. It's not like he landed on taxiway at one of the busiest airports in the world.

Fishfreighter 10-08-2010 06:34 PM

Yeah, tailpipe fires happen on every airline's airplanes everyday. Looks like the media is singling out Allegiant for some unknown reason.

forgot to bid 10-08-2010 06:46 PM


Originally Posted by Shiek Yiboudi (Post 882076)
Like MD80driver said, it was an unfortunate event that happened to a great guy. It's not like he landed on taxiway at one of the busiest airports in the world.

Since you brought it up, would you care to explain what happened to the 767 that landed on taxiway M in ATL? Care to explain what the Feds figured out reproducing the event? Care to talk about where those pilots are now? :rolleyes:

talk about comparing apples and oranges.

Shiek Yiboudi 10-08-2010 07:04 PM


Originally Posted by forgot to bid (Post 882093)
Since you brought it up, would you care to explain what happened to the 767 that landed on taxiway M in ATL? Care to explain what the Feds figured out reproducing the event? Care to talk about where those pilots are now? :rolleyes:

talk about comparing apples and oranges.

No I don't, I don't know anything about it. Just like the guy I was responding to doesn't know anything about this situation, or any other Allegiant operational activities.

captnmajic 10-08-2010 07:18 PM


Originally Posted by Grumble (Post 881990)
.....Back on topic, didn't Allegiant damn near kill 135 people a week ago rotating off the end of a 6500' runway with a calculated TO distance of something like 6525'?


Yep, that's what I'm talking about. Only a matter of time before something real ugly happens.

BeenThere 10-08-2010 08:38 PM

ETOPS on an MD80? What for?

cfiguy11 10-08-2010 09:00 PM


Originally Posted by BeenThere (Post 882146)
ETOPS on an MD80? What for?

I think they're getting 75's for hawaii runs or something. There was a picture posted somewhere of one of them all painted up.

cheers1977 10-08-2010 09:56 PM


Originally Posted by Grumble (Post 881990)
Agreed, what was the company that loaded the cargo, Sabre Tech? IIRC they were found at fault. The accident just put ValueJet under the microscope and then things began to surface.

Back on topic, didn't Allegiant damn near kill 135 people a week ago rotating off the end of a 6500' runway with a calculated TO distance of something like 6525'?


The calculated TO distance wasn't 6525' for the record....

Shiek Yiboudi 10-09-2010 03:43 AM


Originally Posted by captnmajic (Post 882111)
Yep, that's what I'm talking about. Only a matter of time before something real ugly happens.

You didn't bring that up, just vague predictions. What other loss of life situations did you see? You should work for the FAA, they could shutdown operations of airlines that you think are going to crash.

MD80driver2day 10-09-2010 06:46 AM


Originally Posted by captnmajic (Post 882111)
Yep, that's what I'm talking about. Only a matter of time before something real ugly happens.

Quite possible, but not for the reasons you're alluding to.



Originally Posted by cheers1977 (Post 882165)
The calculated TO distance wasn't 6525' for the record....

Exactly.... Obviously these guys here pull things out of their butts without facts in hand. The runway was 6000 feet and they needed all of it +, clearly the ATOGS said 6025... :rolleyes:

If you want a real discussion here, let's talk about complacency. It's not a problem specific to Allegiant and it will cause fatalities again.

SilkBra 10-09-2010 06:46 AM

It's funny to see all the people jealous of Allegiant on this thread. Wasn't it American that overran a runway in Jamaica and destroyed a jet a few months back?

Dozens hurt when American jet overshoots runway in Jamaica | Dallas - Fort Worth News | wfaa.com | Local News

You know, it is just a matter of time before some people really get hurt on an AA jet.

How many MD80s did unsafe Allegiant ground in 2008? Zero. How many did a safe, quality airline like AA ground in 2008? Oh right, it was in the hundreds. Did Allegiant go off the runway in Savannah the other week? Oh no, it was Delta actually.

Which darling cargo airline destroyed an MD11 a few months back? Oh right, that was Fedex.

Which web-board darling destroyed a 747 the other month? Oh right, that was UPS.

So please tell me which airline is perfect and the clear winner to be employed at in the future? You people are simply jealous that Allegiant is profitable, growing, awarding higher pay rates, and pilots at Allegiant are getting fast upgrades. It drives you nuts.

johnso29 10-09-2010 07:00 AM

It really is sad how people are dogging on Allegiant for a fire that could happen to any of us. Not to mention they got the fire put out, and NO ONE was hurt or killed. I say KUDOS to the crew for keeping the situation under control.

In regards to the over run incident with the charter flight, how can anyone blame that on the crew? Do we even know what numbers they got from the company? How do we know they weren't inaccurate? It's extremely possible that the people who loaded the aircraft gave the crew inaccurate information that lead them to believe they were LIGHTER then they actually were.

I think a lot of pilots forget how much we put our lives in the hands of other people everyday. Mechanics, rampers, gate agents, dispatchers, load control, air traffic contol, and the list goes on folks. Rather then try to crucify the pilots, lets praise them for breaking the chain and preventing a tragedy. I for one am much happier to see that no one was hurt or killed, rather then horrific alternative.

BigTime 10-09-2010 09:10 AM

Thanks for the kudos, Jonso, but it sounds like this latest incident was a stupid mistake by the crew that caused a tailpipe fire. Of course this is just rumor and hearsay, but sounds like it wasn't nearly as bad as the media made it sound.

johnso29 10-09-2010 09:19 AM


Originally Posted by BigTime (Post 882315)
Thanks for the kudos, Jonso, but it sounds like this latest incident was a stupid mistake by the crew that caused a tailpipe fire. Of course this is just rumor and hearsay, but sounds like it wasn't nearly as bad as the media made it sound.

Well I hope the crew didn't cause it, but even if they did we ALL make mistakes. It's what makes us human. The most important thing is that no one was hurt. I'd be interested to hear what happened once the investigation is done.

Big3win 10-09-2010 06:15 PM


Originally Posted by johnso29 (Post 882268)
It really is sad how people are dogging on Allegiant for a fire that could happen to any of us. Not to mention they got the fire put out, and NO ONE was hurt or killed. I say KUDOS to the crew for keeping the situation under control.

In regards to the over run incident with the charter flight, how can anyone blame that on the crew? Do we even know what numbers they got from the company? How do we know they weren't inaccurate? It's extremely possible that the people who loaded the aircraft gave the crew inaccurate information that lead them to believe they were LIGHTER then they actually were.

I think a lot of pilots forget how much we put our lives in the hands of other people everyday. Mechanics, rampers, gate agents, dispatchers, load control, air traffic contol, and the list goes on folks. Rather then try to crucify the pilots, lets praise them for breaking the chain and preventing a tragedy. I for one am much happier to see that no one was hurt or killed, rather then horrific alternative.

Just wait until you hear the facts about the charter incident.................................... That is why they are catching so much grief! It will floor you.

MD80driver2day 10-09-2010 06:49 PM


Originally Posted by Big3win (Post 882508)
Just wait until you hear the facts about the charter incident.................................... That is why they are catching so much grief! It will floor you.

Yes it will.... But they're not any different than the NWA crew that overflew MSP or the crew that landed at the wrong airport in SD or the many other major airline crews that have landed on a taxiway.

Many of you run with these Allegiant incidents because it's Allegiant and for no other reason.

I'm sure this crew will see the same fate as those other crews.

DYNASTY HVY 10-09-2010 07:41 PM


Originally Posted by forgot to bid (Post 882093)
Since you brought it up, would you care to explain what happened to the 767 that landed on taxiway M in ATL? Care to explain what the Feds figured out reproducing the event? Care to talk about where those pilots are now? :rolleyes:

talk about comparing apples and oranges.

What was the deal with the taxiway incident ?
No one was hurt in this Allegiant incident and it can happen to anyone at any given time.
These are machines after all and machines do have problems on occasion.




Ally

Stratosphere 10-09-2010 08:09 PM


Originally Posted by MD80driver2day (Post 882520)
Yes it will.... But they're not any different than the NWA crew that overflew MSP or the crew that landed at the wrong airport in SD or the many other major airline crews that have landed on a taxiway.

Many of you run with these Allegiant incidents because it's Allegiant and for no other reason.

I'm sure this crew will see the same fate as those other crews.

Actually the taxiway landings the crews for both airlines in the recent 2 that I can remember did not lose their jobs just went back for additional training if I remember it correctly. Me personally I find a taxiway landing to be a more dangerous situation than a wrong airport landing but I am not the judge or jury on these matters. A tailpipe torch can and has happened before to a lot of airlines. Usually on the DC-9 types it is usually mechanics that do it because they usually do not use checklists and start engines from memory and hold the start switch get it to max motoring and throw the fuel lever and remember Oh I need ignition and reach up and POW..But I have seen pilots do it too although not very often. I think you guys should cut the G4 guys some slack you don't have to look far to see mistakes in your own house.

Big3win 10-09-2010 08:33 PM


Originally Posted by MD80driver2day (Post 882520)
Yes it will.... But they're not any different than the NWA crew that overflew MSP or the crew that landed at the wrong airport in SD or the many other major airline crews that have landed on a taxiway.

Many of you run with these Allegiant incidents because it's Allegiant and for no other reason.

I'm sure this crew will see the same fate as those other crews.

I don't care if it is Allegiant or Acme Air. I stated wait until you hear the facts. Some mistakes are intentional others are not.

Swedish Blender 10-09-2010 09:14 PM


Originally Posted by SilkBra (Post 882258)
Which darling cargo airline destroyed an MD11 a few months back? Oh right, that was Fedex.

Which web-board darling destroyed a 747 the other month? Oh right, that was UPS.

Destroyed a MD11 and 747. How about lost 2 crew members in each accident.

I don't think you'll find a UPS or FedEx pilot jealous of your pay or upgrade.
Way to throw those accidents in to try and make yourself feel better. Class act.

Stratosphere 10-09-2010 09:28 PM


Originally Posted by Swedish Blender (Post 882562)
Destroyed a MD11 and 747. How about lost 2 crew members in each accident.

I don't think you'll find a UPS or FedEx pilot jealous of your pay or upgrade.
Way to throw those accidents in to try and make yourself feel better. Class act.

I am not a pilot (well at least commercial) But will go out on a limb and say he got defensive that Allegient was being attacked without the facts and that all airlines have accidents and incidents. I don't think it was personal. I could always be wrong though.

Herkulesdrvr 10-09-2010 11:13 PM


Originally Posted by captnmajic (Post 881915)
Any of this reminiscent of a blast from the past know as ValuJet? At the current rate of incidents I give them 12-18 months before they have a fatal accident that results in the deaths of many people. Hopefully the FAA is watching and will take necessary steps to break the accident chain.

Wow, you should be thrown off this forum for making such irresponsible statements. You stay classy.

Shiek Yiboudi 10-10-2010 03:45 AM


Originally Posted by Stratosphere (Post 882541)
Actually the taxiway landings the crews for both airlines in the recent 2 that I can remember did not lose their jobs just went back for additional training if I remember it correctly. Me personally I find a taxiway landing to be a more dangerous situation than a wrong airport landing but I am not the judge or jury on these matters. A tailpipe torch can and has happened before to a lot of airlines. Usually on the DC-9 types it is usually mechanics that do it because they usually do not use checklists and start engines from memory and hold the start switch get it to max motoring and throw the fuel lever and remember Oh I need ignition and reach up and POW..But I have seen pilots do it too although not very often. I think you guys should cut the G4 guys some slack you don't have to look far to see mistakes in your own house.

Thanks for your logic and viewpoint. It's easy to bash a small company that is growing in a bad economy. Admittedly, we are not perfect but CRM came about way before Allegiant started up. Aviation history is full of examples of pilot error accidents and equipment malfunctions.

SilkBra 10-10-2010 07:44 AM


Originally Posted by Stratosphere (Post 882565)
I am not a pilot (well at least commercial) But will go out on a limb and say he got defensive that Allegient was being attacked without the facts and that all airlines have accidents and incidents. I don't think it was personal. I could always be wrong though.

There you go.

Swedish Blender 10-10-2010 11:00 AM


Originally Posted by SilkBra (Post 882647)
There you go.

Not really. Someone posts regarding maintenance and/or performance calculations so you throw in FedEx and UPS. Neither of those accidents will be attributed to the reasons people are bashing Allegiant.

Classy.

KC10 FATboy 10-10-2010 11:52 AM

I think the point people are trying to make about Allegiant is, for a company that has limited flight schedules/hours flown, there seems to be a rash of incidents/bad press lately. Is it all bad luck or is there something deeper?

And for those of you who threw other companies/airman who have errored/perished under the bus as a way of propping yourselve's up (for example ... "well so and so crashed a perfectly good jet last month"), shame on you. That is the lowest of lows. You know what they say, Karma is a itch.

MD80driver2day 10-10-2010 02:47 PM


Originally Posted by Big3win (Post 882552)
I don't care if it is Allegiant or Acme Air. I stated wait until you hear the facts. Some mistakes are intentional others are not.

I know exactly what you stated.... I know the facts of this incident. Of course they didn't do what they did with malice, but they did it nonetheless.

MD80driver2day 10-10-2010 02:51 PM


Originally Posted by KC10 FATboy (Post 882738)
I think the point people are trying to make about Allegiant is, for a company that has limited flight schedules/hours flown, there seems to be a rash of incidents/bad press lately. Is it all bad luck or is there something deeper?

And for those of you who threw other companies/airman who have errored/perished under the bus as a way of propping yourselve's up (for example ... "well so and so crashed a perfectly good jet last month"), shame on you. That is the lowest of lows. You know what they say, Karma is a itch.

I think it's a combination. We certainly seem to have some luck issues lately, but we clearly have a problem with complacency and if we don't nip it in the bud now, our luck will go from bad to holy crap.

Boeing717Driver 10-10-2010 04:54 PM


Originally Posted by johnso29 (Post 882268)
It really is sad how people are dogging on Allegiant for a fire that could happen to any of us. Not to mention they got the fire put out, and NO ONE was hurt or killed. I say KUDOS to the crew for keeping the situation under control.

In regards to the over run incident with the charter flight, how can anyone blame that on the crew? Do we even know what numbers they got from the company? How do we know they weren't inaccurate? It's extremely possible that the people who loaded the aircraft gave the crew inaccurate information that lead them to believe they were LIGHTER then they actually were.

I think a lot of pilots forget how much we put our lives in the hands of other people everyday. Mechanics, rampers, gate agents, dispatchers, load control, air traffic contol, and the list goes on folks. Rather then try to crucify the pilots, lets praise them for breaking the chain and preventing a tragedy. I for one am much happier to see that no one was hurt or killed, rather then horrific alternative.

Probably one of the best response posts in this thread. Really now folks. A tail pipe fire. It can happen to any one of us jet drivers. Might be you tommorrow. Just saying...........

Cant believe that the ValuJet thing was brought up here either...geesh! No comparison whatsoever........

Boeing717Driver

Big3win 10-10-2010 08:25 PM

[QUOTE=MD80driver2day;882809]I know exactly what you stated.... I know the facts of this incident. Of course they didn't do what they did with malice, but they did it nonetheless.[/QUOTe


Yup, they sure did.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:18 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands