Ed Bastian letter to Bernie Sanders
#11
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jun 2015
Posts: 4,116
Likes: 1
Yup.
If i recall the pilot pension payment termination was the first order they put in front of the judge after filing. The very next morning i believe.
He didnt ask the judge for relief in a % reduction...noooo. Terminate.
Almost with a flavor of malice.
If our cba doesnt take this opportunity to take our ceo to task for selective memory.....well. Lets just say you all arent getting your dues moneys worth.
Wtf good is an obscure billboard on Va ave? Call him on this whitewash. In the medium of his choosing.
If i recall the pilot pension payment termination was the first order they put in front of the judge after filing. The very next morning i believe.
He didnt ask the judge for relief in a % reduction...noooo. Terminate.
Almost with a flavor of malice.
If our cba doesnt take this opportunity to take our ceo to task for selective memory.....well. Lets just say you all arent getting your dues moneys worth.
Wtf good is an obscure billboard on Va ave? Call him on this whitewash. In the medium of his choosing.
#12
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jun 2015
Posts: 4,116
Likes: 1
I am not sure how you had a 140,000 earned and accrued payout. Given your still working now and your age in 2004 that would have required a FAE of about 400,000. Possible but not easy to do back then unless you had a massive amount of green slips.
As far as the claim I did not mention it. The note was negotiated and directly tied to the pension. In fact the 650 million dollar note was only payable if the pension plan was terminated. Had the plan survived there was no note payment.
Your age 60 payout is about 13,000 a year more than mine. Your age 65 payout is exactly the same. Not sure why that is. Your 65 payment should be higher based on the FAE and your age 60 amount. I would ask the PBGC for a accounting. For perspective I have a friend who was hired one year earlier than me at NWA. His frozen benefit is 84,000 a year. He was a 757 CA at the time.
As far as the claim I did not mention it. The note was negotiated and directly tied to the pension. In fact the 650 million dollar note was only payable if the pension plan was terminated. Had the plan survived there was no note payment.
Your age 60 payout is about 13,000 a year more than mine. Your age 65 payout is exactly the same. Not sure why that is. Your 65 payment should be higher based on the FAE and your age 60 amount. I would ask the PBGC for a accounting. For perspective I have a friend who was hired one year earlier than me at NWA. His frozen benefit is 84,000 a year. He was a 757 CA at the time.
Yes....im corrected.
your math with the prorata is accurate. the fae was there for a 140k at maturity only. With the fractional years service discount im in your ballpark with age 60 rough math of DB/pbgc ~$100k/~$65k.
I dont have the pbgc estimate in hand but i recall the age 60-65 spread is abt $1500 a month.
Still a poke in the eye given the ensuing economic performance, and this moralizing by a ceo who lost sleep over not inflicting enough damage to the pilot group.
The note and claim payed out at a substantial discount as W2 income. Along with the mpp $ i hope all of us have been fortunate in parlaying those resources into some improved financial circumstance.
But im still po'd. Lol.
Last edited by BobZ; 05-21-2019 at 06:26 AM.
#13
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 20,879
Likes: 194
The trigger was there but im recalling a dance around stating it was a direct pension offset because it would 'complicate' the termination?
Yes....im corrected.
your math with the prorata is accurate. the fae was there for a 140k at maturity only.
With the fractional years service discount im in your ballpark with age 60 rough math of DB/pbgc ~$100k/~$65k.
I dont have the pbgc estimate in hand but i recall the age 60-65 spread is abt $1500 a month.
Still a poke in the eye given the ensuing economic performance, and this moralizing by a ceo who lost sleep over not inflicting enough damage to the pilot group.
The note and claim payed out at a substantial discount as W2 income. Like yourself i hope all of us have parlayed those resources into some improved circumstance.
But im still po'd. Lol.
Yes....im corrected.
your math with the prorata is accurate. the fae was there for a 140k at maturity only. With the fractional years service discount im in your ballpark with age 60 rough math of DB/pbgc ~$100k/~$65k.
I dont have the pbgc estimate in hand but i recall the age 60-65 spread is abt $1500 a month.
Still a poke in the eye given the ensuing economic performance, and this moralizing by a ceo who lost sleep over not inflicting enough damage to the pilot group.
The note and claim payed out at a substantial discount as W2 income. Like yourself i hope all of us have parlayed those resources into some improved circumstance.
But im still po'd. Lol.
The one thing that really irks me is getting no real DC money during the period the plan was frozen. It was promised that if the plan was subsequently terminated the targeted DC plan would be retargeted to make everyone whole. Instead they went to a flat rate.
Overall considering the companies financial state and the 20% funding level of the DB plan we came out remarkably well compared to the other airlines in chapter 11 at the time.
#14
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jun 2015
Posts: 4,116
Likes: 1
I don’t like any of it either but Delta pilots claiming they lost their pension are pushing credible boundaries. My and your PBGC payout at age 65 matches my NWA pilot friend total benefit. Admittedly he was a under achiever and only flew his basic schedule but the MPP plan and note offset that. The MEC looked at both groups retirement numbers and found no real difference between former Delta and former NWA.
The one thing that really irks me is getting no real DC money during the period the plan was frozen. It was promised that if the plan was subsequently terminated the targeted DC plan would be retargeted to make everyone whole. Instead they went to a flat rate.
Overall considering the companies financial state and the 20% funding level of the DB plan we came out remarkably well compared to the other airlines in chapter 11 at the time.
The one thing that really irks me is getting no real DC money during the period the plan was frozen. It was promised that if the plan was subsequently terminated the targeted DC plan would be retargeted to make everyone whole. Instead they went to a flat rate.
Overall considering the companies financial state and the 20% funding level of the DB plan we came out remarkably well compared to the other airlines in chapter 11 at the time.
I watched the Eastern disaster unfold.....it was a very sad outcome.
Of the legacy group APA probably realized the best outcome in protecting accrued earned retirement benefit.
Age 65 has been huge in extending the productive income window. To hazard a guess i think most pilots now having genuine value and ownership of their retirement security are the most influential reasons for not wanting to trade what we have for anything else.
#16
Cloudbase
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts: 565
Likes: 28
From: 717A
Forbes: Delta Air Lines CEO Says Bernie Sanders Got It Wrong On Delta Compensation.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/tedreed/2019/05/21/delta-airlines-ceo-says-bernie-sanders-got-it-wrong-on-delta-compensation/
There's something incredibly ironic about Bernie barking about anti union drives when the article photo is him boarding an Eastern jet. Granted it's a resurrection of the brand and a stock photo, but you get the idea.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/tedreed/2019/05/21/delta-airlines-ceo-says-bernie-sanders-got-it-wrong-on-delta-compensation/
There's something incredibly ironic about Bernie barking about anti union drives when the article photo is him boarding an Eastern jet. Granted it's a resurrection of the brand and a stock photo, but you get the idea.
#17
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Apr 2011
Posts: 5,816
Likes: 5
From: retired 767(dl)
I don’t like any of it either but Delta pilots claiming they lost their pension are pushing credible boundaries. My and your PBGC payout at age 65 matches my NWA pilot friend total benefit. Admittedly he was a under achiever and only flew his basic schedule but the MPP plan and note offset that. The MEC looked at both groups retirement numbers and found no real difference between former Delta and former NWA.
The one thing that really irks me is getting no real DC money during the period the plan was frozen. It was promised that if the plan was subsequently terminated the targeted DC plan would be retargeted to make everyone whole. Instead they went to a flat rate.
Overall considering the companies financial state and the 20% funding level of the DB plan we came out remarkably well compared to the other airlines in chapter 11 at the time.
The one thing that really irks me is getting no real DC money during the period the plan was frozen. It was promised that if the plan was subsequently terminated the targeted DC plan would be retargeted to make everyone whole. Instead they went to a flat rate.
Overall considering the companies financial state and the 20% funding level of the DB plan we came out remarkably well compared to the other airlines in chapter 11 at the time.
#18
Moderator
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts: 7,489
Likes: 480
badflaps, if you were hired in that window, can you tell us what you guys had back then? I've been told you guys had a 401k type plan before, then later were received pensions because the company thought it was a better option. Is this true?
#20
Gets Weekends Off
Joined: Jun 2015
Posts: 4,116
Likes: 1
Bad.....those of us that were still on property when delta filed bankruptcy did not experience what delta did to the retired group.
Its a measure of the character of corporate management that they extracted the greatest pain from those with the least recourse. And with the least opportunity for economic recovery.
Those on property still had a job. And then an added 5 year reprieve from the governor.
Everybody here should appreciate that if management didnt need the active pilot group to continue to move metal we would have faced the same fate.
This is my interpretation of the implied follow on to the 'lost sleep' comment.......the worry was not enough was taken from us....and still have us show up and fly the jets.
They needed us. They had no need for the retired pilots.
Its a measure of the character of corporate management that they extracted the greatest pain from those with the least recourse. And with the least opportunity for economic recovery.
Those on property still had a job. And then an added 5 year reprieve from the governor.
Everybody here should appreciate that if management didnt need the active pilot group to continue to move metal we would have faced the same fate.
This is my interpretation of the implied follow on to the 'lost sleep' comment.......the worry was not enough was taken from us....and still have us show up and fly the jets.
They needed us. They had no need for the retired pilots.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



