Quote:
Originally Posted by higney85
this will not work as an end solution if you roll funds into the Delta 401k. Send a dart to R&I before finding yourself in a lurch by trying this. Essentially, once you roll your TSP or IRA into the delta 401k, it’s not coming back out until separation. Only unconverted (meaning not automatically converting to Roth for mega back door 401k) 401a contributions are eligible to roll out into a Roth IRA while still employed.
Not true. "Rollover Contributions" are tracked as a distinct source, and may be rolled out at any time.
Quote:
Originally Posted by higney85
better solution…. Roll TSP into delta 401k, or any other traditional IRA, now you have a $0 traditional IRA balance, if traditional IRA, don’t close the acct, just zero it out. Then backdoor Roth IRA to the limit. Feel free to use the brokeragelink in the 401k if you want to manage your own investments. If you have Roth and traditional balances in the delta 401k, you will have a traditional and Roth brokeragelink acct (seperate).
On this we agree (as I said), but it's incomplete. The difference is, if you roll it into the 401(k), any after-tax money keeps earning pre-tax gains. If those after-tax funds are instead rolled out into a Roth IRA, then the gains are also tax free. This requires rolling ALL of the Rollover Contributions amount out, since a pro-rata rule applies (you can't say "roll out 100% of my after-tax but 0% of my pre-tax funds"--it comes out pro rated from both types). What you CAN do is designate a different target for pre-tax and after-tax: say, a traditional IRA for pre-tax & a Roth IRA for after-tax. Once that's done, rolling the traditional IRA (with only pre-tax funds) back into your 401(k) preserves your $0 balance in the IRA for next year's "back door" conversion.
You may be thinking of Roth 401(k) funds. Those can't be moved while you're employed (not sure why).
If you want to completely max the so-called "mega back door" option, you need to call Fidelity to move your after-tax money to a Roth IRA. For reasons I've never gotten an explanation for, they won't let you automate it. Putting it into an "in-service Roth 401(k) conversion," which you
can automate--but, at the cost of not being able to move that money out. I spent about two years calling Fidelity every two weeks to move the money, then I decided the amounts were relatively modest enough that the automation was worth not dealing with the hassle, even though that money is now stuck w/ the 401(k). Everyone's situation will be different....