Search

Notices
Hangar Talk For non-aviation-related discussion and aviation threads that don't belong elsewhere

Ukraine conflict

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 05-20-2025 | 06:15 AM
  #6991  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Apr 2011
Posts: 3,268
Likes: 69
Default

Originally Posted by MaxQ
There is a great deal of sympathy for Palestinians in Gaza. For Haitians. For Uighurs. For those with the misfortune of being born in just about any of the global places of human misery.
However:
We are speaking of the expanded invasion of Russia into Ukraine.
The geopolitical consequences of the USA withdrawal of support for Ukraine.

Plus (here speaking for myself) Eastern Europe is a subject I have some knowledge of. The areas you mentioned, not so much. Hence I feel justified throwing my two cents in this thread.

i have taken one thing, in a personal sense, from this thread:
That it is possible to inform oneself about truly complex issues (an admirable thing to do), yet still not grasp fundamentals.
I am not speaking of mere disagreements. I am talking about lacking key base knowledge that prevents one from not just seeing the forest but even realizing that a forest exists.
No matter how much one knows about this or that tree, that extensive tree knowledge never translates into an understanding of the forest.

This thread has caused me to temper my certitude regarding Gaza and other such tragedies as I lack the fundamental knowledge to truly understand a few thoughtful articles and a couple of books written for the general public.
I have been able to witness siloed knowledge with a lack of reflection creating an unwarranted certitude.
Due to that, I temper my opinions. As I see how easy it is to think one understands more than they actually do.
Complex, with you there all the way. Born & raised Army green. Witnessed the war in Vietnam split this country in two.

Killed in the line of duty is closure done clean. Not so much for those left behind without husbands, sons, brothers, dads. Not for those left blind, burned, crippled, deranged. Simply put there will be war always. Explaining why something even AI is too slow, too primitive to sort out. My 2 penny takeaway from our little thread drama here? Otherwise innocent people can’t help blaming each other for what they are or aren’t doing to keep the fire fed. Peace in our time? Probably not.
Old 05-20-2025 | 06:53 AM
  #6992  
Thread Starter
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jun 2022
Posts: 2,212
Likes: 279
Default

Originally Posted by METO Guido
Complex, with you there all the way. Born & raised Army green. Witnessed the war in Vietnam split this country in two.

Killed in the line of duty is closure done clean. Not so much for those left behind without husbands, sons, brothers, dads. Not for those left blind, burned, crippled, deranged. Simply put there will be war always. Explaining why something even AI is too slow, too primitive to sort out. My 2 penny takeaway from our little thread drama here? Otherwise innocent people can’t help blaming each other for what they are or aren’t doing to keep the fire fed. Peace in our time? Probably not.
why do you have beef with people calling out cargo? But not have beef with cargo failing to post an article about what just happened in romania(as an example)?

why did you answer a post meant for cargo and reference yourself in the 3rd person?

can you truly not see the pattern you are laying down? What other conclusions should people come to?

please answer with normal words if you have the integrity
Old 05-20-2025 | 07:44 AM
  #6993  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Apr 2011
Posts: 3,268
Likes: 69
Default

Originally Posted by Hubcapped
why do you have beef with people calling out cargo? But not have beef with cargo failing to post an article about what just happened in romania(as an example)?

why did you answer a post meant for cargo and reference yourself in the 3rd person?

can you truly not see the pattern you are laying down? What other conclusions should people come to?

please answer with normal words if you have the integrity
Chitcan the integrity crap Hub. We’re both long past that mileage marker.
3rd person(meto)is an imaginary sock. Socks are used to open dialogue in disputes so participants can express feelings without shame or guilt. There is no meto no guido. As disclosed previously, just a callout used by round engine yucks I once worked with. Shouted 100 times, funny 100 times. I don’t know Ex. Don’t know anyone commenting here that I’m aware of. Highly unlikely a bot imo. If you ask, he’d probably confirm posting positions where we’ve sharply diverged. Jerry is a council 12 hammer. Hubcapped, Ukraini connected partisan. Justifiably spring loaded to confront any & all dissent of critical support. If ex can dispense w feckless I’m prepared to shelve the sock talk. Okay?



Old 05-20-2025 | 08:30 AM
  #6994  
Thread Starter
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jun 2022
Posts: 2,212
Likes: 279
Default

Originally Posted by METO Guido
Chitcan the integrity crap Hub. We’re both long past that mileage marker.
3rd person(meto)is an imaginary sock. Socks are used to open dialogue in disputes so participants can express feelings without shame or guilt. There is no meto no guido. As disclosed previously, just a callout used by round engine yucks I once worked with. Shouted 100 times, funny 100 times. I don’t know Ex. Don’t know anyone commenting here that I’m aware of. Highly unlikely a bot imo. If you ask, he’d probably confirm posting positions where we’ve sharply diverged. Jerry is a council 12 hammer. Hubcapped, Ukraini connected partisan. Justifiably spring loaded to confront any & all dissent of critical support. If ex can dispense w feckless I’m prepared to shelve the sock talk. Okay?
lol, so non answer it is.

So your position is that a country that has been invaded by a brutal murdering oppressive regime should just give up its land, freedom, and people because war is bad? Despite the FACT that the overwhelming majority of that population is in favor of the current ukranian government and its policy to resist the invasion and subsequent subjugation?
Pretty amazing position from a hubris filled half drunk incoherent narcissist that refers to himself in the 3rd person, whilst sitting in his home protected from the Russian SELF stated goal of reconstituting the USSR and the turmoil that would ensue with our largest trading partner (EU)……

that about sums it up?

if poking fun at you and the RU bot (who magically didnt post an article about the recent romanian vote, nor the ukranian poll supporting zelinsky as an example) is a “ukranian shill” as you put it…..then sure, im a ukranian bot.

Did you serve in the US military? Have you ever put your life on the line to defend your nation?

doubtful….

thank god arrogant cowards like you werent around when alfred was stuck in his swamp furiously writing letters or wed be speaking danish.

If a nation wants to fight, let them, this ends the second russia stops shooting. Not sure why this is so hard for you to understand, but then again youve never risked anything for anyone, yet sit here spouting that hodges doesnt know what hes talking about, and that ukranian daughters should just lay down and get raped by the russian mafia in perpetuity………disgusting


Old 05-20-2025 | 08:39 AM
  #6995  
Excargodog's Avatar
Perennial Reserve
 
Joined: Jan 2018
Posts: 14,081
Likes: 182
Default

Originally Posted by MaxQ
There is a great deal of sympathy for Palestinians in Gaza. For Haitians. For Uighurs. For those with the misfortune of being born in just about any of the global places of human misery.
However:
We are speaking of the expanded invasion of Russia into Ukraine.
The geopolitical consequences of the USA withdrawal of support for Ukraine.

Plus (here speaking for myself) Eastern Europe is a subject I have some knowledge of. The areas you mentioned, not so much. Hence I feel justified throwing my two cents in this thread.

i have taken one thing, in a personal sense, from this thread:
That it is possible to inform oneself about truly complex issues (an admirable thing to do), yet still not grasp fundamentals.
I am not speaking of mere disagreements. I am talking about lacking key base knowledge that prevents one from not just seeing the forest but even realizing that a forest exists.
No matter how much one knows about this or that tree, that extensive tree knowledge never translates into an understanding of the forest.

This thread has caused me to temper my certitude regarding Gaza and other such tragedies as I lack the fundamental knowledge to truly understand a few thoughtful articles and a couple of books written for the general public.
I have been able to witness siloed knowledge with a lack of reflection creating an unwarranted certitude.
Due to that, I temper my opinions. As I see how easy it is to think one understands more than they actually do
.
Originally Posted by Hubcapped
this deserves to be repeated
I find myself in rare agreement with Hub, though probably not in the manner he means.

We (the US) have been involved in a number of long term wars in the post WW2 era, generally with good (if somewhat naive) intentions. Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan, and several of our Mideast incursions we (the corporate we - both the US government and the American people) really didn’t understand the culture of those we were dealing with and sort of arrogantly assumed we’d be doing them a favor by converting them to our culture and they would then be grateful to us for doing that. None of those incursions have worked out particularly well for us - at least not so far. And I speak from personal experience on a couple of those incursions. And like most everybody with me, I had good intentions, but experience is a good teacher. Sometimes the path to hell is indeed paved with good intentions. For all those good intentions, we never convinced the locals by force or bribery of the wisdom of our ways, which doesn’t mean American culture isn’t good or that it shouldn’t be emulated, simply that it must be SOLD to other cultures rather than enforced upon them.

Surely military force in protection of our country is warranted, but most of our recent battles were wars of choice, not defense. And I’ve come through those experiences believing it will likely be more effective if we are simply a good example that they will ultimately CHOOSE to emulate than if we try to force them into our mold. They come from a different background and different history and we have been repeatedly surprised by their unwillingness to be coerced into what we believe is the reasonable thing for them to do. Maybe it’s time to give up on coercive wars of choice.
Old 05-20-2025 | 08:46 AM
  #6996  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Apr 2011
Posts: 3,268
Likes: 69
Default

Originally Posted by Hubcapped
lol, so non answer it is.

So your position is that a country that has been invaded by a brutal murdering oppressive regime should just give up its land, freedom, and people because war is bad? Despite the FACT that the overwhelming majority of that population is in favor of the current ukranian government and its policy to resist the invasion and subsequent subjugation?
Pretty amazing position from a hubris filled half drunk incoherent narcissist that refers to himself in the 3rd person, whilst sitting in his home protected from the Russian SELF stated goal of reconstituting the USSR and the turmoil that would ensue with our largest trading partner (EU)……

that about sums it up?

if poking fun at you and the RU bot (who magically didnt post an article about the recent romanian vote, nor the ukranian poll supporting zelinsky as an example) is a “ukranian shill” as you put it…..then sure, im a ukranian bot.

Did you serve in the US military? Have you ever put your life on the line to defend your nation?

doubtful….

thank god arrogant cowards like you werent around when alfred was stuck in his swamp furiously writing letters or wed be speaking danish.

If a nation wants to fight, let them, this ends the second russia stops shooting. Not sure why this is so hard for you to understand, but then again youve never risked anything for anyone, yet sit here spouting that hodges doesnt know what hes talking about, and that ukranian daughters should just lay down and get raped by the russian mafia in perpetuity………disgusting
Simple. Ukraine is not my home. If you stand in the way of securing our streets, 1st, I really don’t gas where you come from or what you’ve claimed to achieve here. Demand US jeopardy for a trench slog in the Urals, go get in line.

Old 05-20-2025 | 09:21 AM
  #6997  
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Apr 2011
Posts: 3,268
Likes: 69
Default

Originally Posted by Hubcapped
lol, thank god arrogant cowards like you werent around when alfred was stuck in his swamp furiously writing letters or wed be speaking danish.
Who’s Alfred? Speaking Danish..wat? Like it or not, this war & this thread are now more likely into their last act. No yankee gold, no war.
Old 05-20-2025 | 11:30 AM
  #6998  
Thread Starter
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jun 2022
Posts: 2,212
Likes: 279
Default

Originally Posted by METO Guido
Who’s Alfred? Speaking Danish..wat? Like it or not, this war & this thread are now more likely into their last act. No yankee gold, no war.
oh my mistake, for someone who is a self declared military genius and knows better than the nato commander i assumed you knew your military history……….
Old 05-20-2025 | 11:32 AM
  #6999  
Thread Starter
Gets Weekends Off
 
Joined: Jun 2022
Posts: 2,212
Likes: 279
Default

Originally Posted by Excargodog
I find myself in rare agreement with Hub, though probably not in the manner he means.

We (the US) have been involved in a number of long term wars in the post WW2 era, generally with good (if somewhat naive) intentions. Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan, and several of our Mideast incursions we (the corporate we - both the US government and the American people) really didn’t understand the culture of those we were dealing with and sort of arrogantly assumed we’d be doing them a favor by converting them to our culture and they would then be grateful to us for doing that. None of those incursions have worked out particularly well for us - at least not so far. And I speak from personal experience on a couple of those incursions. And like most everybody with me, I had good intentions, but experience is a good teacher. Sometimes the path to hell is indeed paved with good intentions. For all those good intentions, we never convinced the locals by force or bribery of the wisdom of our ways, which doesn’t mean American culture isn’t good or that it shouldn’t be emulated, simply that it must be SOLD to other cultures rather than enforced upon them.

Surely military force in protection of our country is warranted, but most of our recent battles were wars of choice, not defense. And I’ve come through those experiences believing it will likely be more effective if we are simply a good example that they will ultimately CHOOSE to emulate than if we try to force them into our mold. They come from a different background and different history and we have been repeatedly surprised by their unwillingness to be coerced into what we believe is the reasonable thing for them to do. Maybe it’s time to give up on coercive wars of choice.
cool story bot…


how come you didnt post an article about the romanian elections?
how come you didnt post an article about the recent ukranian polling?
how come you didn’t post an article about recent aid packages?

agenda driven traitor

Old 05-20-2025 | 12:17 PM
  #7000  
Line Holder
 
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 1,114
Likes: 102
Default

Originally Posted by Excargodog
I find myself in rare agreement with Hub, though probably not in the manner he means.

We (the US) have been involved in a number of long term wars in the post WW2 era, generally with good (if somewhat naive) intentions. Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan, and several of our Mideast incursions we (the corporate we - both the US government and the American people) really didn’t understand the culture of those we were dealing with and sort of arrogantly assumed we’d be doing them a favor by converting them to our culture and they would then be grateful to us for doing that. None of those incursions have worked out particularly well for us - at least not so far. And I speak from personal experience on a couple of those incursions. And like most everybody with me, I had good intentions, but experience is a good teacher. Sometimes the path to hell is indeed paved with good intentions. For all those good intentions, we never convinced the locals by force or bribery of the wisdom of our ways, which doesn’t mean American culture isn’t good or that it shouldn’t be emulated, simply that it must be SOLD to other cultures rather than enforced upon them.

Surely military force in protection of our country is warranted, but most of our recent battles were wars of choice, not defense. And I’ve come through those experiences believing it will likely be more effective if we are simply a good example that they will ultimately CHOOSE to emulate than if we try to force them into our mold. They come from a different background and different history and we have been repeatedly surprised by their unwillingness to be coerced into what we believe is the reasonable thing for them to do. Maybe it’s time to give up on coercive wars of choice.
Pretty much agree with what you write.
Except you imply that our providing material aid to Ukraine is similar to our involvements in Viet Nam, Afghanistan Mid-east etc. The only one here with similarities are Korea and Iraq-Kuwait.
This is about attempting to keep the main structures of the post WW2 order intact.

We are not attempting to reorder the world as we tried in our post 9/11 wars.
This one is pretty straight forward.
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Boeing Aviator
United
18
03-22-2022 11:04 AM
decrabbitz
FedEx
8
09-18-2021 10:22 PM
HerkDriver
Cargo
5
09-18-2007 01:56 PM
DiamondZ
Cargo
16
03-22-2007 10:38 AM
RockBottom
Hangar Talk
0
08-22-2006 07:35 AM

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



Your Privacy Choices