Pilots -vs- Doctors
#21
For some reason pilots like to try and compare themselves to Doctors. Someone wrote something once comparing flying an ILS with preforming brain surgery. The two are not related at all.
It takes six months and some King tapes to become a professional pilot. Even when trying to compare a professional pilot with a barber it is a stretch.
SkyHigh
It takes six months and some King tapes to become a professional pilot. Even when trying to compare a professional pilot with a barber it is a stretch.

SkyHigh
Professional pilot = barber? No....myth busted.
USMCFLYR
#23
Moderator
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 13,088
Likes: 0
From: B757/767
For some reason pilots like to try and compare themselves to Doctors. Someone wrote something once comparing flying an ILS with preforming brain surgery. The two are not related at all.
It takes six months and some King tapes to become a professional pilot. Even when trying to compare a professional pilot with a barber it is a stretch.
SkyHigh
It takes six months and some King tapes to become a professional pilot. Even when trying to compare a professional pilot with a barber it is a stretch.

SkyHigh
Don't be ridiculous SkyHigh. One may be able to obtain their Commercial certificate in 6 months, but it's unlikely that one will obtain a 121 job that quickly. You of all people should know this.
#25
Prime Minister/Moderator

Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 44,864
Likes: 664
From: Engines Turn or People Swim
#26
Line Holder
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
From: Cessna 172 Right Seat
I wouldn't trust a non-pilot doctor to fly me around just the same as I wouldn't trust a non-doctor pilot to slice me open. If you're a doctor and a pilot, then kudos to you for having more cajones and dedication than me. Either way we're both too much in debt for something I'm sure both groups are equally passionate about. Ahh the beauty of student loans. At least we only need 4 years of school instead of 12 though
#27
If you had said that 2 years ago everyone would have laughed in your face ... now days ... you're absolutely right
#29
Moderator
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 13,088
Likes: 0
From: B757/767
Yeah, I was going to put that in as the exception but it's kind of a moot point. I don't think it will be happening again anytime soon.
#30
From NBC Nightly News (14 Jan 09)
Doctor's acting like pilots in the operating room;
There are 100,000 preventable deaths and post-operation complications every year in hospitals across the US. Doctors are taking a page from pilots in the use of checklists for pre-surgery and even during surgery. The surgeon will come in to speak to the patient and check name, medical problem/procedure and even use his signature to mark the area of concern (left hip for example).
A current study had hoped to find enough patients to show a 15% decrease but the study has shown a 36% decrease in deaths and complication.
Before the surgery, the circulating nurse will check the identification of the surgeon and then at some point call a time-out and check with everyone once more on all critical aspects of the surgery. One good aspect of this according to the doctors in the study is the hierarchy is flattened out in the opearting room and anyone can speak up at anytime if they have any questions on any plan or procedure (think CRM in the way that the surgeon is no longer the only voice in the opearting room)
It seems that two professions can learn from each other. Bravo!
NBC Nightly News with Brian Williams: News and videos from the evening broadcast NBC Nightly News with Brian Williams: News and videos from the evening broadcast- msnbc.com
USMCFLYR
PS.....imagine pilots making mistakes that result in 100,000 injuries or deaths per year!
It makes me appreciate that other news story about US airlines not having a single fatality in over two years. Way to go professionals!
Doctor's acting like pilots in the operating room;
There are 100,000 preventable deaths and post-operation complications every year in hospitals across the US. Doctors are taking a page from pilots in the use of checklists for pre-surgery and even during surgery. The surgeon will come in to speak to the patient and check name, medical problem/procedure and even use his signature to mark the area of concern (left hip for example).
A current study had hoped to find enough patients to show a 15% decrease but the study has shown a 36% decrease in deaths and complication.
Before the surgery, the circulating nurse will check the identification of the surgeon and then at some point call a time-out and check with everyone once more on all critical aspects of the surgery. One good aspect of this according to the doctors in the study is the hierarchy is flattened out in the opearting room and anyone can speak up at anytime if they have any questions on any plan or procedure (think CRM in the way that the surgeon is no longer the only voice in the opearting room)
It seems that two professions can learn from each other. Bravo!
NBC Nightly News with Brian Williams: News and videos from the evening broadcast NBC Nightly News with Brian Williams: News and videos from the evening broadcast- msnbc.com
USMCFLYR
PS.....imagine pilots making mistakes that result in 100,000 injuries or deaths per year!
It makes me appreciate that other news story about US airlines not having a single fatality in over two years. Way to go professionals!
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
B727DRVR
Cargo
14
08-22-2008 02:23 PM



