Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Regional (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/)
-   -   Mesa to Furlough 150 (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/31609-mesa-furlough-150-a.html)

sidestep 10-01-2008 04:58 PM


Originally Posted by Ski Patrol (Post 471040)
So as long as I "man up" get another job within 1 year, 5 year, or 10 year then I can cast judgement on my fellow brother? What is the cut-off?

Who's to say I haven't already.

Man i can't believe no one has taken note of what a great response this was. Knight for you. So much for the alpa "Brotherhood"..

boilerpilot 10-01-2008 05:10 PM


Originally Posted by BURflyer (Post 471941)
Who cares if you lateral, as long as you're doing what makes you happy. As far as those FDX, SWA jobs you think guys at the majors with time on type haven't already applied? Who do you think gets priority? Now is the time more than ever to find a comfortable regional because you're more than likely going to be there for more than a few years. It would suck to be stuck at Mesa, at least they're putting the last 150 on reserve in ORD and IAD out of their misery. Good for those guys, they're probably going to get better qol working at Home Depot.

Is gojet a regional you're comforatble with?

Anyway, if you think that the guys and girls from United, Continental, ETC with 73 types and time get priority over somebody who doesn't, you're fooling yourself. Southwest hires people based off their personalities. If you have a thousand hours of TPIC, you know how to fly. Does a thousand in type help your flying in said aircraft? Of course, but SWA isn't like a regional that hires based off of your chances of making it through training. They base it off of return on investment and, most importantly, how you're going to fit into the company. On the ROI side, you're right that it's good that somebody might have an extra 1000 hours on type, but that is balanced out by how likeliy it's going to be that you're going to leave back to United when you get recalled (likely or not, I should say, that's going to try to be determined during the interview).

You don't have any better chance getting a job if you have 10000 hours, 5000 of those in a 73 than somebody who has 2500 hours in RJs.

Sniper 10-01-2008 10:17 PM

Skywest and Mesa guys, send me the #'s
 
What's the average line worth @ Skywest and Mesa? What's the average upgrade time? Seriously, PM me the data, and I'll run the #'s for both Mesa and Skywest and see, from a pure financial standpoint, where the break-even point is if you make a lateral move after 1 year @ Mesa to Skywest. If I'm wrong, I'll admit it. If I'm right, I'll admit that too.:D

I'd like to shed some objectivity on whether a lateral move is good thing to do financially.

Ski Patrol 10-02-2008 06:12 AM


Originally Posted by sidestep (Post 472008)
Man i can't believe no one has taken note of what a great response this was. Knight for you. So much for the alpa "Brotherhood"..

Well thank you sir.

rickair7777 10-02-2008 06:42 AM


Originally Posted by Sniper (Post 471873)
There's another forum, FI, that's had Mesa info on it since at least 2002. Mesa had a yahoo forum that pilots posted on back in 2001, at least. And the Mesalounge (now Mesahub) existed as early as 2003, a forum dedicated purely to Mesa. All the issues that Mesa has now it had back then (and OO has most of them too - they're regional issues, inherent in any company that doesn't build their own brand, but rather has their schedule dictated to them as a contractor and has employees who aren't there for the long term). The information was out there.

With the exception of a Go Jets or Gulfstream job, I can't understand why guys make lateral moves at regionals. If you'd been hired in 2003 or 2004 at any large regional, you could have been with just about any passenger major airline, and most cargo airlines too. By making a lateral move, you give up the opportunity to be at a major (pay, QOL, career potential) and the opportunity to upgrade earlier (pay - OO doesn't pay their FO's nearly what a Captain makes flying a jet @ a regional, type on the resume, marketability). What did you gain? Hopefully some QOL. But, long term, the QOL at all regionals is not up to par with that of virtually any of the majors, large cargo carriers, or national fractionals. What's the goal, to always chase the pot of gold, or to make a commitment? The best QOL is enjoyed by seniority, and at a good company. Right now, Southwest, Fed Ex, UPS, and Net Jets are the 'in' companies to work for (notice, none are 'regionals'). However, the good life @ all of these companies is when you get some seniority. 10 years would be a good #, at least. 10 years ago, 1998, none of these companies where 'the company' to work for. There were many pilots who left these companies, in fact, to work for the 'in' companies of the day: United was where a lot of them ended up. They gave up seniority at a good company to go to a 'great' one, and now . . . the mighty United is not the 'golden ticket' it once was (here's hoping it gets back there, though). How many guys left United in 1998 to go to Fed Ex, UPS, Southwest or NetJets - I'd bet no more that 5, total, and those only went b/c they needed the base that one of these 4 offered; nobody could have predicted what would happen over the next decade.

To make a lateral move @ a career company makes some sense, if done early, before seniority is built up. To make a lateral move to a company that you plan on leaving makes no sense at all. You make vertical moves at these 'career builders', put your time in, and then make another vertical move to another one, or to a career company. The QOL gain one would get by giving up any more than a year @ YV to go to OP would be pointless unless you lived in SLC. Otherwise, the financial hit (YV CA pay for 2 years instead of OP FO pay is worth about $60-70K now, and almost 1 mil. over your lifetime if invested) and the career hit you'd take is just too much (by going to OP, you give up not only the pay of YV, but also trade how ever many years you spend @ OO for years at your career airline - there goes another $50-150K a year, each year). Even if you live in SLC, you stay @ YV (for example) and now you're competitive for DL. Get on with DL, now you are with the only major that has a SLC base. If you live in SLC, your goal should almost always be DL, not OO.

And if you make a move just for internet 'street credibility' so that you can go on a regional forum and join the majority - well, then you have different values than most, especially those on the 'major forum', which is where you want to be in the first place, no doubt.

OO is a good company today, but don't lose sight of the long term goal. If it's OP, congrats, and I wish you the best in your career. Great seniority @ OP and living in base can be a good life, and here's hoping that doesn't change.

As I've said before, I did not adequately research mesa. FI is 100% useless, and I didn't find any other info. A friend hooked me up with an interview at a time when they were hard to get. I'm not making excuses...but learn from my experience:

Newbies: Don't Do It
MAG FO's: Get Out ASAP


Mesa did something stupid, and my pride and self-respect would not have allowed me to stay under any circumstances...even if no other flying jobs were available.

OO is not the long-term goal, but it is an acceptable plan B. Even if I could have convinced myself to stay at MAG for a few years in hopes of faster career progression, the prospect of getting stuck there long-term was inconceivable. 1000 hours TPIC in a MAG RJ won't necessarily open a lot of doors.

The timing at OO was very good...my first upgrade opportunity arrived at OO at the same time it would have at mesa, had I stayed.

The QOL, respect for human dignity, and pay are far better at SKW. Only a senior mesa 900 CA comes anywhere close to SKW pay. The best part for me was going from 8 to 18 days off/month in one year :eek:

As a long-term plan B SKW is fine, but like any regional, there is no guarantee of stability. SKW probably has better options than most however...if necessary they could probably buy UAL to ensure continuity of their contract.

Ski Patrol 10-02-2008 08:26 AM


Originally Posted by rickair7777 (Post 472311)
Mesa did something stupid, and my pride and self-respect would not have allowed me to stay under any circumstances...even if no other flying jobs were available.

It's OK I know alot of sharp pilots who have busted a ride.


Originally Posted by rickair7777 (Post 472311)
1000 hours TPIC in a MAG RJ won't necessarily open a lot of doors.

So 1000 TPIC at MAG is worth less than from another airline.:confused: I agree in part though, 1000 TPIC doesn't assure anything anymore. Other than you can join the other 20,000 apps on file at xx airline.


Originally Posted by rickair7777 (Post 472311)
The timing at OO was very good...my first upgrade opportunity arrived at OO at the same time it would have at mesa, had I stayed.

The QOL, respect for human dignity, and pay are far better at SKW. Only a senior mesa 900 CA comes anywhere close to SKW pay. The best part for me was going from 8 to 18 days off/month in one year :eek:

Congrats on your move working out. Seriously I'm glad you found greener pastures.

rickair7777 10-02-2008 08:32 AM


Originally Posted by Ski Patrol (Post 472394)
It's OK I know alot of sharp pilots who have busted a ride.

??? Huh? Nope, not me.

I said that MESA did something stupid, not that I did something stupid...I fired them, not vice versa :rolleyes:

I don't think SKW hires people who got fired by mesa.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 03:56 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands