Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Regional (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/)
-   -   UAX XJTers in ORD (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/regional/53874-uax-xjters-ord.html)

thndr8 10-04-2010 11:47 AM


Originally Posted by shfo (Post 879991)
Also you are always cleared to land unless told otherwise. .

Sorry dude, If I don't hear "cleared to land" I'm going around. There are alot of unwritten rules at many airports, just don't forget the basics and common sense.

ToiletDuck 10-04-2010 12:39 PM


Originally Posted by thndr8 (Post 880071)
Sorry dude, If I don't hear "cleared to land" I'm going around. There are alot of unwritten rules at many airports, just don't forget the basics and common sense.

Yea that's one I'm not comfortable with myself. If I don't hear clear to land I'm not doing it. I'm not paying for the fuel if I go missed but I'm betting my career if I don't.

goaround2000 10-04-2010 02:42 PM

Not so much!
 

Originally Posted by shfo (Post 879991)

Also you are always cleared to land unless told otherwise.The controller said you are always cleared to land and you are always cleared to taxi to your gate if it is open. If it is not open you are cleared to taxi to the box. If I see a safety conflict with any of those we will tell you to do something else.

I appreciate you sharing, BUT we should apply a little common sense here. First of all, ORD had one of the closest near misses ever recorded in history between a United 737 and an Atlas 747 a couple of years ago, you would think our friendly folks in the tower would be a bit more cautious about saying things like that to anyone.

Second, there's no way I am landing without a clearance, unless I'm declaring an emergency, particularly in an airport as big as ORD with crossing runways (please see above).

Finally, let's talk about self preservation here, what if you have a fed on board? Yes right there in your jumpseat! Or what if you're on a line check? Are you going to land without a clearance? And if you didn't have a fed or a check airman, why would you even consider breaking a regulation, while increasing your margin of risk?

As far as taxing, I will comply with any "tribal" norms and unspoken rules, within the limits of both the regulations, but most importantly safety, and I really don't give a sh!t if it disturbs their flow. I will not hit another vehicle and or aircraft, nor will I expose myself to a runway/taxiway incursion for which the controllers are now liable to report. I've been in and out of ORD plenty of times, but we run the aircraft, not ATC, and I've never had any problems.

No demeanor to the ATC folks, but they will try to get away with as much as we let them, after all, they are subject to operational pressures just as much as anyone else in this business.

chuckyt1 10-04-2010 03:14 PM

If you deem it as the safest course of action by all means. I have landed at ORD without a clearance. If you don't have a landing clearance at ORD it's probably because they are tied up with the aircraft that is going around.

UAL used to teach an initial Captains course and this was one of the questions that they asked - You can't get a word in on the radio because ATC is busy with... You can see the runway is clear. Do you land or go around? The answer that they, and ATC wanted to hear was land.

goaround2000 10-04-2010 03:19 PM


Originally Posted by chuckyt1 (Post 880141)
If you deem it as the safest course of action by all means. I have landed at ORD without a clearance. If you don't have a landing clearance at ORD it's probably because they are tied up with the aircraft that is going around.

UAL used to teach an initial Captains course and this was one of the questions that they asked - You can't get a word in on the radio because ATC is busy with... You can see the runway is clear. Do you land or go around? The answer that they, and ATC wanted to hear was land.

Once again, my job is not to tailor the flying of my aircraft to accomodate ATC's flow, but rather to operate the aircraft as safely as possible within the regulations, and/or under emergency authority. That being said, I am more than happy to work WITH our ATC brothers and sisters, there is a big distinction.

TurboFan 10-04-2010 04:05 PM


Originally Posted by shfo (Post 879991)
Also you are always cleared to land unless told otherwise.

Having been ORD based at one point in my career I can sympathize with the craziness that occurs around there, however I would not heed this advice. It's one thing to keep moving after clearing the runway while the ground frequency is tied up, it is quite another to land without a clearance. With all the crossing runways and intersection departures going on at that airport your decision to land without a clearance could be your last.

Regardless of what anyone has told you, I would not land without a clearance.

dojetdriver 10-04-2010 04:46 PM


Originally Posted by IFly17 (Post 879931)
Finally, when exiting a runway, keep moving. A couple weeks ago, I had the great sit on M short of M2 waiting for my gate. We watched a guy clear 10, and he could not get a word in on ground so he stopped (lot of hangar repos, and foreign crews so it was crazy on ground). The plane behind him had to roll to the next taxiway before he could clear and the third guy had to go around. A few minutes later, an American 757 did the same thing and the sequence repeated itself. We watched 2 go arounds in maybe 15 minutes. Figure out the flow of traffic and keep moving. Ground knows you're there, he'll get to you.

Well, are you going to post in the majors section to AA pilots about your hints and tips about flying in and out of ORD?

The majority of the go arounds I see in ORD are due to ATC pooching the screw, not crews from (insert airline here). Just like when I was LGA based, BOS based, IAD based, LAX based, etc.

IFly17 10-04-2010 09:50 PM


Originally Posted by dojetdriver (Post 880169)
Well, are you going to post in the majors section to AA pilots about your hints and tips about flying in and out of ORD?

The majority of the go arounds I see in ORD are due to ATC pooching the screw, not crews from (insert airline here). Just like when I was LGA based, BOS based, IAD based, LAX based, etc.

I mention the two go arounds I have witnessed because of people taking their sweet time getting off the runway. How many have I seen go around for other reasons? Plenty. You jump on my case "because I have been based [here], and [here], and [here]".... come on, get your panties out of a wad. We all know they happen. I am trying to help, not stir up a ruckus. Posts like yours do not help.

Oh, and that AA 757 not only stopped, but did so with half his airplane across the hold short line. Maybe I should go into the flight training forum and ask the pre-private students where you stop after crossing a hold short line since apparently the major guys you reference with your sarcastic remarks don't seem to know and post the answer in the majors forum.... I am trying to offer what I have learned to help make everyone's lives easier, you decide to try get things fired up. Since you have been based everywhere, you sure seem to know better.

And by the way, it is screwing the pooch, not "pooching the screw," though I wonder what that means. Guess being based everywhere means proper English no longer matters.

dojetdriver 10-04-2010 10:36 PM

Theres always decaf......


Originally Posted by IFly17 (Post 880255)
I mention the two go arounds I have witnessed because of people taking their sweet time getting off the runway. How many have I seen go around for other reasons? Plenty. You jump on my case "because I have been based [here], and [here], and [here]".... come on, get your panties out of a wad. We all know they happen. I am trying to help, not stir up a ruckus. Posts like yours do not help

I was simply saying that there's more than one reason for a go around. Show me where I "jumped on your case" as you put it. Careful with the bold part, you can get zinged for flambebait with that language. A former mod is probably spinning right now wishing he still had that authority


Originally Posted by IFly17 (Post 880255)
Oh, and that AA 757 not only stopped, but did so with half his airplane across the hold short line. Maybe I should go into the flight training forum and ask the pre-private students where you stop after crossing a hold short line since apparently the major guys you reference with your sarcastic remarks don't seem to know and post the answer in the majors forum.... I am trying to offer what I have learned to help make everyone's lives easier, you decide to try get things fired up. Since you have been based everywhere, you sure seem to know better

You chose to start a thread about a specific airline, yet elected to include another airline that has committed a foible, why? So do as you wish. I'm guessing neither you, nor anybody at the airline that employs you has EVER made a boo boo at one of the world's busiest airports? Or simply stopped the airplane awaiting further instructions because as professional and safe pilots that what we're trained to do?


Originally Posted by IFly17 (Post 880255)
And by the way, it is screwing the pooch, not "pooching the screw," though I wonder what that means. Guess being based everywhere means proper English no longer matters.

You picked up on sarcasm earlier, how it got lost here is beyond me, sorry. :rolleyes:

XJT Pilot 10-05-2010 07:48 AM

A Heavy plane still on the end of the runway about to make his turn clear. Me...over the numbers...to ATC "What do u want me to do" ATC LAND! never heard a word and never saw past the first third of the RWY, sorta like landing at Sun-in-Fun...A

Still a jacked up place, but we make it work, work with the guys and they will always work with you...good and bad


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:17 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands