Airline Pilot Central Forums

Airline Pilot Central Forums (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/)
-   Safety (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/safety/)
-   -   Air France, Comair, fender bender (https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/safety/58608-air-france-comair-fender-bender.html)

DD214 04-11-2011 07:15 PM

Jumbo Air France jet clips COM 6293
 
Jumbo Air France jet clips smaller plane at New York's JFK airport - CNN.com

APC225 04-11-2011 07:23 PM

Air France, Comair, fender bender
 
NEW YORK (CBSNewYork/AP) – An Air France Airbus A380 collided with a Delta commuter plane while taxiing to the runway for takeoff from John F. Kennedy International Airport on Monday night.

The Federal Aviation Administration’s Jim Peters said at approximately 8:15 p.m. the left wing of Paris-bound Air France Flight 7 struck the tail of Comair Flight 6293, which had just landed from Boston with 62 passengers and 4 crew on board. No injuries were reported. Passengers were removed from the Comair flight and both planes were towed.

AbortAbortAbort 04-11-2011 07:28 PM

http://flamesnation.ca/uploads/Image/scooby_ruh_roh.jpg


Going to guess the whale won.

rickair7777 04-11-2011 07:38 PM

I would have thought the wing of an A380 would be higher than the tail of a 200...

Does AF even have A380's?

rightside02 04-11-2011 07:54 PM

Man I was taxing there on a jet blue flight commuting home when it happened, I just barely missed it ...

rightside02 04-11-2011 07:56 PM

Read it was a Crj 700, none the less yeah you would think the wing is taller than the tail of the other

scambo1 04-11-2011 07:58 PM

poor taste alert:

something about scope karma here.

WstCstCmtr 04-11-2011 08:27 PM

yes they have 380s... just saw it in JFK the other day and they start flying it to IAD in June going from 3 777s -to- 1 777 and 1 380.

CaptainCarl 04-11-2011 08:31 PM

Pics or it didn't happen :)

Columbia 04-11-2011 08:42 PM


Originally Posted by CaptainCarl (Post 979041)
Pics or it didn't happen :)

Two Planes Collide on Ground at JFK | NBC New York :eek:

9ESOCCFI 04-11-2011 08:54 PM

Well I have seen pictures at work and it looks like the impact spun the CRJ about 60 degrees to the left. There are wrinkles and buckling on the fuselage of the RJ. It disrupted operations there at the DL regional gates for about an hour.

TBucket 04-11-2011 09:40 PM

The video on the bottom of that link is pretty crazy... Bet it was one heck of a ride for the guys up front...

nerd2009 04-12-2011 02:36 AM

It's amazing that the tail didn't rip off. Are there any pictures of the damaged planes?

captainv 04-12-2011 02:38 AM

pics, plus video without the commercial

Air France Airbus A380 Clips Smaller Delta Jet at Kennedy Airport in New York | NYCAviation

nfnsquared 04-12-2011 03:20 AM

Uh, "Clear right". "Clear le..., oh sh!t..."

Can't blame the FO for this one....

uafurlough 04-12-2011 04:52 AM

The airplane/wing of the A380 sits fairly low, compared to a B747. I believe it's one of the reasons it only has inboard thrust reverser's (so the outboard's don't ingest FOD, on narrower runways).

samballs 04-12-2011 05:15 AM

Maybe the AF pilots are sick of DCI carriers blocking up every taxiway in JFK waiting to get into the crappiest terminal and parking spots in the country. Either way right now DL management is going to DALPA and asking for scope relief because of this (they'll need lets say 40 more 76 seaters for this. And DALPA will respond sure why not we always are happy to give up scope). Or finally if this was a Comair plane DL is just happy this plane is gone off their certificate.

Phuz 04-12-2011 05:21 AM

CNBC says "it probably wasn't a good idea to taxi in front of the a380"

Sliceback 04-12-2011 06:19 AM

pprune has head on pictures. The CRJ tail is leaning about 10-15 degrees to the left(the exact opposite of what I would have expected).

It's more than a fender bender. Have to wonder if a tail bent that much, and the twisting of the fuselage, can be repaired.

rickair7777 04-12-2011 06:26 AM


Originally Posted by Phuz (Post 979132)
CNBC says "it probably wasn't a good idea to taxi in front of the a380"

Looked stationary to me, I think the CA guys are off the hook if they pass the whiz quiz.

But yeah, that was no fender bender. Damn frogs anyway...was it just me or did they have indicated airspeed on that taxi?

ToiletDuck 04-12-2011 06:30 AM

The audio has air france being told to hold short for traffic which obviously they didn't do.

Op's check good!

rickair7777 04-12-2011 06:31 AM


Originally Posted by Sliceback (Post 979159)
pprune has head on pictures. The CRJ tail is leaning about 10-15 degrees to the left(the exact opposite of what I would have expected).

It's more than a fender bender. Have to wonder if a tail bent that much, and the twisting of the fuselage, can be repaired.

Maybe not, at $22M new it might be cheaper to scrap it for parts.

I guess they can do a heavy check, rebuild the LDG gear to be safe, and go over the structure with a micrometer to check for warping. Plus the new tail.

It might cost more to fix the 380 than to replace the RJ if they have to tear open the wing structure to check for damage.

nfnsquared 04-12-2011 07:03 AM


Originally Posted by ToiletDuck (Post 979167)
The audio has air france being told to hold short for traffic which obviously they didn't do.

Op's check good!

Source? Link?

crewdawg 04-12-2011 07:12 AM

and this, my friends, is why you keep your seatbelt on until you reach the gate. I just love the people that have to get their seatbelt off and be the first stand up...to go nowhere!

DelDah Capt 04-12-2011 07:32 AM


Originally Posted by ToiletDuck (Post 979167)
The audio has air france being told to hold short for traffic which obviously they didn't do.

I don't feel like going back and listening to the clip again, so admittedly my memory may be off, but what I heard was the A380 get cleared from his ramp to turn left onto Twy A and then to hold short/give way to traffic at Twy KD which is much further along A than where the collision occured. The collision occurred at Twy M and I never heard Ground give any warnings to Air France to give way there. By the same token, I'd be surprised if the Air France didn't at least see the CR7 waiting to enter the ramp at M and just didn't judge the wingtip clearance correctly

CaptainCarl 04-12-2011 09:21 AM

Let's put this fancy "embed" feature to use:


cessna157 04-12-2011 09:35 AM


Originally Posted by ToiletDuck (Post 979167)
The audio has air france being told to hold short for traffic which obviously they didn't do.

Op's check good!

I haven't heard the archive audio, so I cannot speak with 100% certainty, but the clip that has been posted is edited (so further clearances may have been edited out) and that feed is a scan of both ground frequencies (so other clearances may have been scanned over). There's most likely other conversations that took place that we're not hearing.

I doubt the Capt would be get away


Originally Posted by rickair7777 (Post 979163)
Looked stationary to me, I think the CA guys are off the hook if they pass the whiz quiz.
But yeah, that was no fender bender. Damn frogs anyway...was it just me or did they have indicated airspeed on that taxi?

I doubt the capt would get away scott free, drug test or not. They did not maintain wingtip clearance and hit the Comair jet.

SoCalGuy 04-12-2011 10:34 AM

AirFrance A380 & Comair CRJ play "tag" at JFK
 
The video speaks for itself....Anyone at JFK last night (Monday) to see this live & in person??
(04/11/2011)

YouTube - Air France Plane Collide @JFK... As seen in new channel [JFK - USA]

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2011/04/11...-city-airport/

ATC Audio....
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WjuCI2yAVD8

11Fan 04-12-2011 10:48 AM

Comin through.... scuse me, pardon me, scuse me.......

AZFlyer 04-12-2011 10:50 AM

Wow. The CRJ was tossed like a toy. Crazy. Had to be super startling for everyone on the CRJ.

norskman2 04-12-2011 10:52 AM

Here's how it REALLY happened:

YouTube - Parody-Air France A380 Collides With Delta CRJ-700 at JFK

:D

acl65pilot 04-12-2011 10:56 AM

If that OH nose wheel was lifted off the ground, it may have been part of the reason why the tail was not torn off. Impressive to say the least.

rickair7777 04-12-2011 11:06 AM


Originally Posted by cessna157 (Post 979298)

I doubt the capt would get away scott free, drug test or not. They did not maintain wingtip clearance and hit the Comair jet.

I was talking about the COMAIR (CA) pilots. Also known as OH.

The AF Capt is toast...he's on video taxiing in a congested area with indicated airspeed, and he did probably somewhere between $15-40M in damage.

FlyJSH 04-12-2011 11:27 AM

It appears he was taxiing at about 23 mph (it took 7 seconds for the bus to pass, 240 ft in 7 seconds is about 23 mph).

forgot to bid 04-12-2011 12:53 PM

holy cow!!!

a380, impounded? with wheel boots?

GBU-24 04-12-2011 01:10 PM

Another reason to get rid of RJs! You heard it here..."Toy Planes"! Squeal like a pig RJ!

cencal83406 04-12-2011 02:17 PM


Originally Posted by rickair7777 (Post 979329)
I was talking about the COMAIR (CA) pilots. Also known as OH.

The AF Capt is toast...he's on video taxiing in a congested area with indicated airspeed, and he did probably somewhere between $15-40M in damage.

If he's issued a violation by the FAA... does that matter to the French Civil Aviation Authority? Will he not be allowed to exercise privileges in USA?

BlueMoon 04-12-2011 02:20 PM


Originally Posted by ToiletDuck (Post 979167)
The audio has air france being told to hold short for traffic which obviously they didn't do.

Op's check good!

They were told to Hold short of E and give way to traffic at KD...both are considerably further down from taxiway M where this occurred.

Stallog 04-12-2011 03:00 PM

Looks more like an A340:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2StZVDUck9M

ERJF15 04-12-2011 03:12 PM


Originally Posted by GBU-24 (Post 979374)
Another reason to get rid of RJs! You heard it here..."Toy Planes"! Squeal like a pig RJ!

That didn't take long :cool:


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:15 PM.


Website Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands