Quote:
Originally Posted by LoneStar32
So ysay in one case government intervention would make matters worse but in the other they would make them better. What makes you think that? What makes you think that more (because the federal government did intervene IRT Covid, just not as much as you would have liked) federal government intervention in the COVID response wouldn't have made matters worse just like you claim they have in Portland? (they have not btw, you just didn't like that protesters were not as easily able to get away with crimes and violence)
Yes, a coordinated federal response would have helped. In some cases, the federal government actively withheld aid from states. Why has every other country that responded from the top-down got this under control? You can't answer that.
And I don't like masked federal agents abducting innocent people without cause. They have constituional rights, and just because you don't like their politics doesn't mean they deserve to be wrongly imprisoned by unidentified thugs. How would you feel if armed federal agents showed up to your house and demanded your guns? Constituional rights are constitutional rights, and wrong is wrong.
Since you're not listening to me, here is Judge Andrew Napolitano of Fox News, someone who knows more about what's lawful and constitutional than either you or me:“
What happened in Portland over the weekend, it was not only unlawful and unconstitutional, it’s just plain wrong. Sending armed, untrained police into the streets wearing fatigues without the knowledge or consent of the local police
actually caused more violence.”
Napolitano also talked about a complaint by Oregon's attorney general against DHS that included
allegations of kidnapping and blindfolding:
“You have a lot of peaceful demonstrators,” Napolitano argued. “The complaint filed by the attorney general of Oregon against the Department of Homeland Security recounts
horror stories of peaceful people being kidnapped, held blindfold, handcuffed, and incommunicado for just two hours and then let go. There is no reason to disturb those people. The people they should stop are the ones with the baseball bats.”
“The federal government
can’t do what it doesn’t have the authority to do,” he added. “And it shouldn’t do anything without the coordination of the locals.”