Quote:
Originally Posted by tm602
Especially in a very dynamic environment like NJA has. I'm not necessarily saying anything one way or the other over a retirement age "number", but there needs to be some cognitive testing done as age advances. Not some BS simulator ride where the gouge gets out and you're the only plane in the sky etc. Something that is done by mental health professionals. Flame away, but biology is biology. Some hold on better than others and this a way to prove it. You have it or you lost it. Some by age 45 are checked out, and I have seen guys in their 70s holding on well.
Well that's just the thing, there's no set age where cognitive decline begins. And worse, some (albeit very few), were never particularly sharp to begin with. So at what age do we begin testing people for cognitive decline? Seems like picking an age would end up being just another random number we will hate. And it'd be discriminatory. A cognitive test would have to be given to everyone.
Furthermore, which test do we use? There actually is not any standard test that is recognized in the scientific community as being able to reliably identify cognitive decline. Sure, there are some tests that are pretty good at identifying cognitive issues when they become serious, such as identifying Altzheimer's, but nothing exists to truly identify a more "normal" cognitive decline. Since everyone is different, what's the baseline? How do you know if someone has deteriorated from where they were before if you never measured where they started from?
It's really not the same as physical health. And speaking of which, we all know the FAA medicals we take are a joke. Should we tighten up those standards too? We could eliminate some of the older pilots that way. But we need to be prepared to see a lot of younger folks be dismissed too.
You can't just "target" older pilots with tests. Maybe it can be done legislatively, like the age 65 rule for 121 operators, but coming up with tests that are specifically meant to weed out older pilots is illegal and unethical.