"Records related to an individual acting as pilot in command or second in command during an aviation accident or incident."
I'm not 100% certain what this even means.
An "accident" has a specific definition, and is reported to the NTSB, not the FAA.
So we're talking NTSB reportable accidents? Do they mean company records? Post-accident drug tests results?
Disciplinary records? That usually carries some privacy protections, if nothing else implied by the threat of lawsuit but I guess federal law could over-ride that.