You really cannot apply "corporate America" rules (which is rife with politics, ass-kissing, favoritism, nepotism, etc.) to the airline industry - pilots (FAs, mechanics, etc) are labor, not really different than an assembly line worker. Instead of making widgets, they make airplanes move.
Given the scale and nature of the airline industry, there are dozens if not hundreds of reasons why it simply will not work.
Quote:
If the responsibility was on the company to provide excellent pay/QOL to attract employees then there would be little need for a union.
The reality of that quote is this:
if the company provided excellent pay/QOL, there would be no need for a union. Unfortunately, pilots being labor are viewed by most airline management teams as replaceable financial liabilities, and not human assets. Because of this failure to properly manage & exploit the asset that is human capital, companies in general and airlines specifically get the unions they deserve...